Question 1

Why is the word order bu cins bir kedi rather than bu bir cins kedi?

Accepted Answer

In Turkish, when a noun has both an adjective or descriptive modifier (like cins) and the indefinite article bir, the order is almost always [Modifier] + bir + [Noun]. The demonstrative bu goes at the very front, creating the literal structure "this breed a cat".

Question 2

Is cins acting as a noun or an adjective here?

Accepted Answer

Cins is inherently a noun meaning "breed", "kind", or "gender". However, Turkish frequently allows nouns to be placed directly before other nouns to act as modifiers. Here, it functions adjectivally to describe the type of cat.

Question 3

What is the exact suffix breakdown for the past tense question var mıydı?

Accepted Answer

It breaks down as var (existent) + mı (question particle) + -y- (buffer consonant) + -dı (past tense). For existential sentences and noun predicates, the past tense always attaches to the question particle rather than the word itself. Saying vardı mı is grammatically incorrect.

Question 4

Could we use a past form of olmak (like oldu mu) instead of var mıydı?

Accepted Answer

Not in this context. Var mıydı asks about a continuous state of existence in the past ("Was there...?"). The verb olmak focuses on an event, transition, or action ("to become" or "to happen"), so using oldu mu would confusingly ask if the cat "happened" or "became" on the poster.

Afişte bu cins bir kedi var mıydı?

Breakdown of Afişte bu cins bir kedi var mıydı?

Questions & Answers about Afişte bu cins bir kedi var mıydı?

Learn Afişte bu cins bir kedi var mıydı and more in Turkish