Question 1

Why do we use the subjunctive hagas here instead of the normal present tense haces?

Accepted Answer

The phrase es esencial que (it is essential that) is an impersonal expression showing a necessity or opinion. These types of phrases trigger the subjunctive mood in the second part of the sentence because they express a requirement rather than stating a concrete fact.

Question 2

How exactly do we get the subjunctive form hagas from the verb hacer?

Accepted Answer

To form the present subjunctive for irregular verbs like hacer, start with the "yo" (I) form of the regular present tense, which is hago. Drop the final -o to get the stem (hag-), and then add the opposite vowel endings. Since hacer is an -er verb, it takes -ar endings in the subjunctive. For tú (you), that ending is -as, giving us hagas.

Question 3

The English translation says "before eating". Why doesn't Spanish use the -ndo form (comiendo)?

Accepted Answer

In Spanish, whenever a verb directly follows a preposition like de (found here in the phrase antes de), it must be in the infinitive form (comer). While English naturally uses the "-ing" form after prepositions, Spanish never uses the -ndo form there.

Question 4

Could I say antes de que comas instead of antes de comer?

Accepted Answer

Not in this case. You only use antes de que followed by a subjunctive verb when there is a change of subject (for example, "It's essential that you do the work before I eat"). Because the same person (you) is both doing the work and eating, you must use the shorter antes de followed by the infinitive comer.

Es esencial que hagas el trabajo antes de comer.

Breakdown of Es esencial que hagas el trabajo antes de comer.

Questions & Answers about Es esencial que hagas el trabajo antes de comer.

Learn Es esencial que hagas el trabajo antes de comer and more in Spanish