Breakdown of Mientras subamos, escucharemos los rieles temblar.
los
the (masculine plural)
escuchar
to listen
temblar
to shake
mientras
while / the more/less (in proportional comparisons) / as long as
subir
to go up / to rise
el riel
rail
Questions & Answers about Mientras subamos, escucharemos los rieles temblar.
Why does this sentence use the infinitive temblar instead of the gerund temblando?
With perception verbs like escuchar, using the infinitive means you perceive the entire action, or it focuses on the fact that the action happens ("we will hear the rails shake"). If we used the gerund temblando, it would emphasize an action already in progress at the exact moment we listen ("we will hear the rails shaking"). Both are perfectly correct here, just with a slight shift in focus.
Why is subamos in the subjunctive here instead of the indicative (subimos)?
Because the action hasn't happened yet! When mientras (while) refers to an anticipated future event—as shown by the future tense escucharemos—it requires the subjunctive. If you were talking about a habitual routine ("while we go up, we usually hear..."), you would use the indicative mientras subimos.
If I wanted to replace los rieles with a pronoun and say "we will hear them shake", where does the pronoun go?
You place the object pronoun before the conjugated perception verb: los escucharemos temblar. While attaching it to the end of the infinitive (escucharemos temblarlos) is grammatically possible, putting it before the main conjugated verb is much more natural and common.
Can I change the word order to escucharemos temblar los rieles?
Yes, absolutely. With perception verbs followed by an infinitive, Spanish word order is very flexible. You can put the object before the infinitive (escucharemos los rieles temblar) or after it (escucharemos temblar los rieles). Both sound perfectly natural.
Learn Mientras subamos, escucharemos los rieles temblar and more in Spanish
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
- ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
- ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free