Log inSign up

De repente, houve um tumulto na assembleia.

De repente, houve um tumulto na assembleia.
Suddenly, there was an uproar in the assembly.
From Lesson 275:There was and there were (houve / havia)·Portuguese (Portugal)

Questions & Answers about De repente, houve um tumulto na assembleia.

Why does this sentence use houve instead of havia for "there was"?
This is the core difference between the two past tenses! We use houve (the Pretérito Perfeito, or simple past) because the phrase de repente ("suddenly") tells us this was a single, abrupt event. If you wanted to describe an ongoing background situation (like "There was an uproar going on for hours"), you would use havia (the Pretérito Imperfeito).
If there were multiple uproars, would houve change to a plural form?
No, it stays exactly the same. When haver is used to mean "there is" or "there are", it acts as an impersonal verb and only ever takes the third-person singular form. So, "there were multiple uproars" would still be houve vários tumultos.
Could I use foi or esteve here, since they also mean "was" in the past?
No. While foi and esteve are the past forms of the verbs for "to be" (ser and estar), they do not mean "there was". To express that something exists or that an event happened, Portuguese strictly uses haver (which becomes houve or havia in the past).
Is de repente a fixed expression?
Yes, de repente is a fixed phrase meaning "suddenly" or "all of a sudden". Because it points to a sudden, contained event rather than a continuous one, it is a great clue that the verb following it will be in the simple past tense (like houve) rather than the ongoing past.

Learn De repente, houve um tumulto na assembleia and more in Portuguese

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
  • ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
  • ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free
Start learning Portuguese →