Word
Mój pies jest mi zawsze posłuszny, ale nigdy nie jest uległy mojej żonie.
Meaning
My dog is always obedient to me, but he is never submissive to my wife.
Part of speech
sentence
Pronunciation
Course
Breakdown of Mój pies jest mi zawsze posłuszny, ale nigdy nie jest uległy mojej żonie.
być
to be
pies
dog
ja
I
nie
no / not
Questions & Answers about Mój pies jest mi zawsze posłuszny, ale nigdy nie jest uległy mojej żonie.
Why are mi and mojej żonie in the Dative case in this sentence?
This is due to the adjectives posłuszny (obedient) and uległy (submissive). In Polish, certain adjectives dictate the grammatical case of the noun or pronoun that completes their meaning. Both of these adjectives require the Dative case for the person or thing being submitted to or obeyed.
Why do we use the short pronoun mi here instead of the long form mnie?
You should use the short, unstressed form mi because there is no special emphasis on the word "me" here. The long form mnie in the Dative case is used for contrast or emphasis (like saying "he is obedient to ME, not you"), at the very beginning of a sentence, or after a preposition. Since this is just a neutral statement mid-sentence, mi is the correct choice.
Why is the word order mi zawsze posłuszny (pronoun before adjective) but uległy mojej żonie (noun phrase after adjective)?
While Polish word order is flexible, short pronouns like mi act as "clitics"—they avoid being at the very end of a clause and prefer to latch onto a verb, which is why it sits close to jest. On the other hand, a full noun phrase like mojej żonie carries more weight and comfortably sits right after the adjective uległy, which is the standard, neutral position for the object of an adjective.
What are the rules for forming the Dative phrase mojej żonie from moja żona?