Past passive with modal verbs (kunne ha blitt, burde ha blitt)

In a post-incident safety or project review, you often look back at what could, should, or would have been done differently. Norwegian expresses this with the modal perfect passive: a past-form modal (kunne, burde, skulle, ville) + ha blitt + a past participle.

Past possibilities with kunne ha blitt

To say that something could have been done, chain four verb forms:

  • kunne (could, past form of kan)
  • ha (have, bare infinitive after a modal)
  • blitt (been, past participle of the passive auxiliary å bli)
  • past participle of the main verb (normally unchanged for gender and plural)

Useful verbs here:

  • å forhindre (to prevent) → forhindret (regular -et participle)
  • å forutse (to foresee) → forutsett (formed like sett from å se)

Word order around the chain:

  • Sentence adverbs such as lett (easily) or nok (probably) go after kunne and before ha blitt: kunne lett ha blitt forhindret.
  • Yes/no questions put kunne first, then the subject, then ha blitt
    • participle.
  • The agent (who could have done it) is introduced by av (by): av ingeniøren (by the engineer).
This accident could have been prevented.
Denne ulykken kunne ha blitt forhindret.
The failure in the engine could easily have been prevented.
Svikten i motoren kunne lett ha blitt forhindret.
Could this failure have been foreseen by the engineer?
Kunne denne svikten ha blitt forutsett av ingeniøren?
The problem could probably have been foreseen in the planning.
Problemet kunne nok ha blitt forutsett i planleggingen.

Unfulfilled obligations with burde ha blitt

To say what should have been done, replace kunne with burde: burde ha blitt + past participle.

  • et avvik → avviket (the discrepancy, neuter; definite plural avvikene: disse avvikene, these discrepancies)
  • å rapportere → rapportert (reported)
  • å avdekke → avdekket (uncovered)

When the agent after av is a personal pronoun, use the object form: av henne (by her), av ham (by him).

The discrepancy should have been reported to the boss right away.
Avviket burde ha blitt rapportert til sjefen med en gang.
All the errors should have been reported by her yesterday.
Alle feilene burde ha blitt rapportert av henne i går.
The leak should have been uncovered during the inspection.
Lekkasjen burde ha blitt avdekket under inspeksjonen.
These discrepancies should have been checked before the inspection.
Disse avvikene burde ha blitt kontrollert før inspeksjonen.

Planned vs. hypothetical: skulle ha blitt and ville ha blitt

  • skulle ha blitt
    • participle (was supposed to have been …): an agreed plan, deadline, or rule was not followed, e.g. å utbedre (to rectify) → utbedret.
  • ville ha blitt
    • participle (would have been …): the hypothetical result if conditions had been different.
Modal perfect passiveMeaningTypical review context
kunne ha blitt + participlecould have been …A missed possibility
burde ha blitt + participleshould have been …A neglected duty or recommendation
skulle ha blitt + participlewas supposed to have been …An unfulfilled plan, rule, or deadline
ville ha blitt + participlewould have been …The outcome under different conditions

In all four, only the modal is finite, and in a main-clause statement it takes second position (V2). Sentence adverbs like egentlig (actually) follow the modal; if an adverbial such as Med bedre prosedyrer (With better procedures) starts the sentence, the subject comes between the modal and ha blitt:

Position 1Finite modal (position 2)Subject / adverbNon-finite passive chainRest of clause
Feilenskulleegentligha blitt utbedretav ham før fristen.
Med bedre prosedyrervillefeilenha blitt avdekkettidligere.
The damage on the roof was supposed to have been rectified last week.
Skaden på taket skulle ha blitt utbedret forrige uke.
The fault was actually supposed to have been rectified by him before the deadline.
Feilen skulle egentlig ha blitt utbedret av ham før fristen.
The new procedure was supposed to have been approved by the management.
Den nye prosedyren skulle ha blitt godkjent av ledelsen.
With better procedures, the fault would have been uncovered earlier.
Med bedre prosedyrer ville feilen ha blitt avdekket tidligere.
The risk would have been discovered faster through the evaluation.
Risikoen ville ha blitt oppdaget raskere gjennom evalueringen.
The matter would have been resolved faster after a thorough evaluation.
Saken ville ha blitt løst raskere etter en grundig evaluering.

Contributors