Comparative clauses (enn hva som, enn det)

When comparing an actual outcome against an earlier estimate or expectation, English says larger than (what) was expected or longer than she had thought. In Norwegian, after a comparative such as større (larger), mer (more), høyere (higher) or lengre (longer), enn (than) is often followed by hva (what) or det (that / what) to introduce a comparative clause. Whether som follows depends on whether hva/det is the subject of the clause or the clause has its own subject.

Enn hva som (when hva is the subject)

Key words:

  • en overskridelse (an overrun), definite overskridelsen
  • et anslag (an estimate), definite anslaget
  • en entreprenør (a contractor), definite entreprenøren
  • å overskride (to exceed): overskrider – overskred – har overskredet
  • et fundament (a foundation), definite fundamentet
  • betong (concrete), definite betongen
  • stål (steel), definite stålet
  • en konstruksjon (a structure, a construction), definite konstruksjonen
  • ei bru (a bridge), definite brua

When the clause after enn hva has no other subject (typical with was expected, was agreed, was calculated), hva is the subject, and Norwegian then requires som after it: enn hva som + verb (than what was …). English has no equivalent word here, so som is easy to forget.

The overrun was larger than what was expected in the first estimate.
Overskridelsen ble større enn hva som var forventet i det første anslaget.
The contractor exceeded the budget by more than what was agreed.
Entreprenøren overskred budsjettet med mer enn hva som var avtalt.
The foundation under the bridge required more concrete than what was calculated.
Fundamentet under brua krevde mer betong enn hva som ble beregnet.
The steel for the structure cost more than what was estimated in advance.
Stålet til konstruksjonen kostet mer enn hva som var anslått på forhånd.

Enn hva + subject + verb

Key words:

  • å sprenge (to blast, to blow up): sprenger – sprengte – har sprengt
  • en belastning (a load, a strain), definite belastningen

When the clause has its own subject (hun, han, entreprenøren), hva is the object of the verb or preposition, so there is no som: enn hva + subject + verb. The clause uses normal subordinate word order, with the subject right after hva:

It took longer to blast the tunnel than she had thought.
Det tok lengre tid å sprenge tunnelen enn hva hun hadde trodd.
The structure withstands a higher load than he had counted on.
Konstruksjonen tåler høyere belastning enn hva han hadde regnet med.
Why did the new estimate turn out higher than the contractor promised us?
Hvorfor ble det nye anslaget høyere enn hva entreprenøren lovet oss?

Enn det som and enn det (som)

Instead of enn hva (som), Norwegian very often uses det (that which) followed by a relative clause: enn det (som) …. The meaning is the same, and this version is common in both everyday and formal prose.

The rule for som is almost the same:

  • det as subject → enn det som + verb: with no other subject in the clause, som is required.
  • det as object → enn det (som) + subject + verb: when the clause has its own subject (hun, han, vi, de), som is optional and usually dropped. Enn det som vi fryktet is also correct. This differs from hva, which never takes som here.

Enn det som, with det as the subject:

Is the overrun really worse than what is in the report?
Er overskridelsen virkelig verre enn det som står i rapporten?
We need more concrete and steel than what was ordered.
Vi trenger mer betong og stål enn det som ble bestilt.
During the storm, the load on the bridge became greater than what was expected.
Under stormen ble belastningen på brua større enn det som var forventet.

Enn det + its own subject, with som left out:

We had to blast deeper into the mountain than she had planned.
Vi måtte sprenge dypere i fjellet enn det hun hadde planlagt.
The costs are going to exceed the budget faster than we feared.
Kostnadene kommer til å overskride budsjettet raskere enn det vi fryktet.
The contractor should have examined the mountain more thoroughly than they did before the construction.
Entreprenøren burde ha undersøkt fjellet grundigere enn det de gjorde før byggingen.

Summary

StructureRole of hva/detExample
enn hva som + verbSubjectstørre enn hva som var forventet (larger than what was expected)
enn hva + subject + verbObjectlengre tid enn hva hun hadde trodd (longer than she had thought)
enn det som + verbSubjectmer enn det som ble bestilt (more than what was ordered)
enn det (som) + subject + verbObjectraskere enn det vi fryktet (faster than we feared)

Contributors