Word
Lo scrittore era vecchio quando è morto, ma è nato povero.
Meaning
The writer was old when he died, but he was born poor.
Part of speech
sentence
Pronunciation
Course
Breakdown of Lo scrittore era vecchio quando è morto, ma è nato povero.
essere
to be
vecchio
old
ma
but
quando
when
Questions & Answers about Lo scrittore era vecchio quando è morto, ma è nato povero.
Why do we use era for being old, but è morto and è nato for dying and being born?
era (imperfect tense) describes an ongoing state or background condition in the past; he was old for a period of time. Dying (è morto) and being born (è nato) are specific, completed events that happened at a precise moment, so they use the passato prossimo.
Why do morto and nato use è as their helping verb instead of ha?
Both morire (to die) and nascere (to be born) describe a major change of state or a life event. Verbs of movement, state, and change of state take essere (to be) as their helping verb in the passato prossimo, rather than avere (to have).
If the writer were female, what would happen to the words morto and nato?
In English we say he was born. Why is it translated as è nato instead of era nato?