Question 1

Why do we use era for being old, but è morto and è nato for dying and being born?

Accepted Answer

era (imperfect tense) describes an ongoing state or background condition in the past; he was old for a period of time. Dying (è morto) and being born (è nato) are specific, completed events that happened at a precise moment, so they use the passato prossimo.

Question 2

Why do morto and nato use è as their helping verb instead of ha?

Accepted Answer

Both morire (to die) and nascere (to be born) describe a major change of state or a life event. Verbs of movement, state, and change of state take essere (to be) as their helping verb in the passato prossimo, rather than avere (to have).

Question 3

If the writer were female, what would happen to the words morto and nato?

Accepted Answer

They would change to morta and nata. When a past tense verb uses essere as its helper, the past participle ending must agree with the subject's gender and number. The adjectives would also change, making the sentence: La scrittrice era vecchia quando è morta, ma è nata povera.

Question 4

In English we say he was born. Why is it translated as è nato instead of era nato?

Accepted Answer

English uses the past tense of to be (was) for birth, but Italian treats nascere (to be born) as an active verb. Since his birth is a completed event, you use the standard passato prossimo, which pairs the present tense helper è with the participle nato. Using era nato would actually mean he had been born.

Lo scrittore era vecchio quando è morto, ma è nato povero.

Breakdown of Lo scrittore era vecchio quando è morto, ma è nato povero.

Questions & Answers about Lo scrittore era vecchio quando è morto, ma è nato povero.

Learn Lo scrittore era vecchio quando è morto, ma è nato povero and more in Italian