Breakdown of Después de leer la revista, mi hermana la tira a la papelera.
Questions & Answers about Después de leer la revista, mi hermana la tira a la papelera.
Why is it después de leer?
Because in Spanish, después de is normally followed by a noun or an infinitive.
So leer stays in the infinitive form because it comes after the preposition de.
A structure like después leer is incorrect here, and después que... is a different pattern that usually introduces a full clause, for example después de que mi hermana lee/leyó..., though that is not what this sentence is doing.
Why is it leer and not leyendo or leyó?
After a preposition like de, Spanish normally uses the infinitive, not the gerund and not a conjugated verb.
So:
- después de leer = after reading
- not después de leyendo
- not después de leyó
If you want a full clause with a subject, then you need something different, such as después de que leyó la revista. But when the idea is simply after doing something, Spanish prefers después de + infinitive.
What does the la before tira mean?
That la is a direct object pronoun, and it refers back to la revista.
So:
- la revista = the magazine
- la = it
The second part literally works like:
- mi hermana la tira a la papelera = my sister throws it in the bin
Spanish often uses an object pronoun instead of repeating the noun again.
Why is the pronoun placed before the verb: la tira?
With a normal conjugated verb, object pronouns usually go before the verb:
- la tira
- lo compra
- las lee
They are attached to the end only in certain cases, especially with:
- infinitives: tirarla
- gerunds: tirándola
- affirmative commands: tírala
So in this sentence, la tira is the normal position.
Why not repeat the noun and say mi hermana tira la revista a la papelera?
You can say that, and it is perfectly grammatical.
But Spanish often avoids repeating a noun that has just been mentioned. Since la revista already appears in después de leer la revista, the next clause naturally uses la to mean it.
So both are possible:
- Después de leer la revista, mi hermana la tira a la papelera.
- Después de leer la revista, mi hermana tira la revista a la papelera.
The version with la sounds more natural because it avoids repetition.
Why is it a la papelera and not en la papelera?
Because tirar often expresses movement toward / into somewhere, so Spanish commonly uses a.
- tirar algo a la basura
- tirar algo a la papelera
This is similar to the idea of throw something into the bin.
Using en can sometimes appear in other contexts, but with tirar, a is very common because it marks the destination of the action.
Why is it a la papelera and not al papelera?
Because papelera is a feminine noun:
- la papelera
The contraction al only happens with a + el:
- a + el parque = al parque
But with feminine la, there is no contraction:
- a + la papelera = a la papelera
So al papelera is incorrect.
Why is tira in the present tense if the reading happens first?
The present tense here usually suggests a habitual action or a general sequence:
- After reading the magazine, my sister throws it in the bin.
So the sentence can mean this is what she normally does.
Spanish, like English, can use the present tense to describe a routine:
- lee la revista
- la tira a la papelera
The fact that one action happens before the other is already shown by después de.
What exactly does papelera mean in Spain?
In Spain, papelera commonly means a wastepaper bin, trash bin, or small bin, especially one indoors or in a public place.
So here it means something like:
- bin
- wastebasket
Depending on the country, other words are also common, such as:
- basura
- cubo de basura
- bote de basura
But papelera is very natural in Spain.
Why is there a comma after revista?
Because Después de leer la revista is an introductory time phrase, and Spanish often separates that kind of opening phrase with a comma:
- Después de leer la revista, mi hermana la tira a la papelera.
It helps mark the pause and makes the sentence easier to read. In short sentences, punctuation can vary a little, but the comma here is standard and natural.
Could the sentence also be Mi hermana la tira a la papelera después de leer la revista?
Yes. That word order is also grammatical.
Both versions mean basically the same thing:
- Después de leer la revista, mi hermana la tira a la papelera.
- Mi hermana la tira a la papelera después de leer la revista.
The version with Después de leer la revista first gives the time/background information up front. That is why it feels slightly more natural if the speaker wants to emphasize the sequence of actions.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning SpanishMaster Spanish — from Después de leer la revista, mi hermana la tira a la papelera to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions