Breakdown of Hace diez minutos que prueba la combinación del cofre.
Questions & Answers about Hace diez minutos que prueba la combinación del cofre.
Why does the sentence start with hace?
Here hace is part of the time expression hace + period of time + que + verb.
In this pattern, it means:
someone has been doing something for X amount of time
So:
Hace diez minutos que prueba la combinación del cofre
= He/She has been trying the safe/chest combination for ten minutes
This is different from the more basic use of hace in:
Hace diez minutos = ten minutes ago
The full structure changes the meaning.
Why is prueba in the present tense if the action started in the past?
Because Spanish often uses the present tense for an action that started earlier and is still continuing now, especially in this structure:
Hace diez minutos que + present tense
So prueba does not mean only tries here in a simple present sense. In this construction, it corresponds to English:
has been trying
That is why Spanish does not need a separate present perfect continuous form here.
Why is it prueba and not está probando?
Both can be possible in Spanish, but they are not used in exactly the same way.
In this sentence, prueba is the normal choice because the structure hace + time + que + present tense commonly uses the simple present:
Hace diez minutos que prueba...
If you say Hace diez minutos que está probando..., it is also understandable and adds a stronger sense of the action being in progress right now, but the simple present is the more standard textbook pattern.
So:
- prueba = the usual form in this construction
- está probando = possible, with extra emphasis on the ongoing action
Who is doing the action? Why is there no subject?
Spanish often leaves out the subject pronoun when it is understood from the verb form or from context.
Prueba can mean:
- he tries / is trying
- she tries / is trying
- you (formal) try / are trying
So by itself, the sentence does not tell you exactly who the subject is. You need context.
If you wanted to make it explicit, you could say:
- Hace diez minutos que él prueba la combinación del cofre
- Hace diez minutos que ella prueba la combinación del cofre
- Hace diez minutos que usted prueba la combinación del cofre
But normally Spanish prefers to omit the pronoun unless needed.
What does que mean here?
Why is it del cofre and not de el cofre?
What does la combinación del cofre mean exactly?
It means the combination of the chest/safe, or more naturally in English:
the safe combination
or
the combination for the chest/safe
A few vocabulary notes:
- combinación here means a lock combination / code
- cofre can mean chest, strongbox, or sometimes safe, depending on context
In everyday modern Spanish, if you specifically mean a safe, many speakers would often say caja fuerte. But cofre is still understandable and can fit certain contexts.
Why is there an article in la combinación?
Spanish uses definite articles more often than English.
Here la combinación refers to a specific combination: the one belonging to the cofre.
So Spanish naturally says:
prueba la combinación del cofre
where English might say:
tries the safe combination
or
tries the combination to the safe
The article sounds normal and expected in Spanish.
Could this sentence also be said in another way?
Yes. A very common alternative is:
Lleva diez minutos probando la combinación del cofre.
This also means:
He/She has been trying the safe combination for ten minutes.
Another possible version is:
Prueba la combinación del cofre desde hace diez minutos.
So Spanish has several ways to express this idea:
- Hace diez minutos que prueba...
- Lleva diez minutos probando...
- ... desde hace diez minutos
All are grammatical, though llevar + time + gerund is especially common in everyday speech.
Could hace diez minutos mean ten minutes ago here?
Not in this full sentence.
On its own:
Hace diez minutos = ten minutes ago
Example:
Llegó hace diez minutos. = He/She arrived ten minutes ago.
But in your sentence, you have:
Hace diez minutos que prueba...
That whole pattern means:
He/She has been trying ... for ten minutes
So the meaning changes because of the full construction, especially que + present tense.
Is this sentence natural in Spanish from Spain?
Yes, it is grammatical and understandable.
That said, in everyday speech many speakers in Spain might be more likely to say something like:
- Lleva diez minutos probando la combinación de la caja fuerte.
- Lleva diez minutos intentando abrir el cofre.
Why?
- llevar + time + gerund is very common in conversation
- caja fuerte is often more common than cofre if you mean a safe
So your sentence is correct, but depending on the exact context, a native speaker might choose a slightly different wording.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning SpanishMaster Spanish — from Hace diez minutos que prueba la combinación del cofre to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions