Breakdown of Она тащила большой чемодан по лестнице, потому что лифт снова не работал.
Questions & Answers about Она тащила большой чемодан по лестнице, потому что лифт снова не работал.
Why is the verb тащила used here? What does it suggest?
Тащила comes from тащить, which means to drag, to haul, or to lug something with effort.
So она тащила большой чемодан suggests more than just she carried a big suitcase. It implies that the suitcase was heavy, awkward, or difficult to move. A more neutral verb like несла would simply mean was carrying.
So the choice of тащила adds a sense of strain.
Why does the verb end in -а: тащила?
Why is it тащила and not a perfective verb?
Тащила is imperfective, and that fits the sentence well because it describes an ongoing process or background situation.
The sentence is telling us what she was doing when the reason is given:
- Она тащила большой чемодан по лестнице, потому что лифт снова не работал.
This sounds like a scene in progress: she was hauling the suitcase along the stairs because the elevator was out again.
A perfective verb would usually focus more on a completed result, such as successfully getting the suitcase somewhere. Here the emphasis is on the action itself, not its completion.
Why is it большой чемодан? What case is that?
Большой чемодан is the direct object of the verb тащила, so it is in the accusative case.
However, with inanimate masculine singular nouns, the accusative looks exactly like the nominative:
- nominative: большой чемодан
- accusative: большой чемодан
So even though it is accusative, the form does not change.
Why is the adjective большой in that form?
The adjective must agree with the noun чемодан in:
- gender
- number
- case
Чемодан is:
- masculine
- singular
- accusative in this sentence
For an inanimate masculine singular noun, the accusative adjective form is the same as the nominative form, so we get:
- большой чемодан
If the noun were feminine, for example, the form would change differently.
What case is по лестнице, and why is по used here?
По лестнице is in the dative case.
The preposition по often means along, on, over, or via, depending on context, and it commonly takes the dative.
Here, по лестнице means something like:
- along the stairs
- on the stairs
- by the stairs / using the stairs
In natural English, we usually translate it as up the stairs or down the stairs, depending on context.
The noun лестница becomes лестнице in the dative singular.
Does по лестнице mean up the stairs or down the stairs?
By itself, по лестнице does not explicitly say up or down.
Literally, it is more like along/on the staircase. In real usage, the exact direction is often understood from context.
So depending on the situation, English might translate it as:
- up the stairs
- down the stairs
- on the stairs
If Russian needs to make the direction completely clear, it can add words like:
- вверх по лестнице — up the stairs
- вниз по лестнице — down the stairs
Why is there a comma before потому что?
Because потому что introduces a subordinate clause.
Russian normally separates subordinate clauses with a comma:
- Она тащила большой чемодан по лестнице, потому что лифт снова не работал.
This is very standard punctuation.
Why is it лифт снова не работал?
This means the elevator was not working again or the elevator wasn’t working again.
A few things are happening here:
- лифт is the subject, so it is in the nominative
- работал is masculine singular past tense, agreeing with лифт
- не работал means was not working
- снова means again
So the clause literally works as:
- elevator again not worked → the elevator wasn’t working again
Could снова be replaced with опять?
Yes. In many contexts, снова and опять both mean again.
So you could say:
- лифт снова не работал
- лифт опять не работал
The difference is mostly stylistic:
- снова is often a bit more neutral
- опять is often a bit more conversational and can sometimes sound more emotional or slightly annoyed
Since a broken elevator is annoying, опять would sound very natural too.
Why is it не работал instead of сломался?
Because не работал focuses on the state: the elevator wasn’t working.
- лифт не работал = the elevator was out of order / wasn’t functioning
- лифт сломался = the elevator broke
Those are related, but not identical.
In this sentence, the speaker is giving the reason she had to use the stairs. The important point is the elevator’s condition at that time, so не работал is a very natural choice.
Why is the pronoun она included? Could Russian leave it out?
Russian can sometimes omit subject pronouns, but in the past tense the verb does not show person clearly the way present-tense forms do.
For example, тащила tells you:
- feminine
- singular
- past
But it does not tell you whether it means I, you, or she without context.
So она is useful here because it clearly identifies the subject as she.
Where is the word the in this sentence? Why doesn’t Russian use articles?
Russian has no articles like a or the.
So nouns like чемодан, лестница, and лифт appear without articles, and definiteness is understood from context.
For example:
- большой чемодан could mean a big suitcase or the big suitcase
- лифт could mean an elevator or the elevator
In this sentence, context makes it natural in English to say the elevator and probably a big suitcase or the big suitcase, depending on the situation.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning RussianMaster Russian — from Она тащила большой чемодан по лестнице, потому что лифт снова не работал to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions