Breakdown of A professora diz que cada aluno é responsável pelo seu próprio estudo.
Questions & Answers about A professora diz que cada aluno é responsável pelo seu próprio estudo.
In European Portuguese:
- A professora = the teacher (female). The definite article a is normally used before professions when you’re talking about a specific person (a specific teacher).
- Portuguese does not normally use a subject pronoun plus a full noun the way English sometimes does (e.g. A professora ela diz…). You just say A professora diz….
So:
- A professora diz… = The (female) teacher says…
- You would only say Professora, diz… if you’re directly addressing her (like “Teacher, say…”), and then Professora works more like a form of address, not the subject of the sentence.
- Professora is feminine because we are clearly talking about a female teacher.
- Aluno is grammatically masculine, but in Portuguese the masculine singular can be used in a generic way for “each student” (male or female).
Alternatives:
- cada aluno – grammatically masculine, but can be understood as “each student (in general)”.
- cada aluna – “each (female) student”, only females.
- cada aluno e cada aluna – explicitly mentions both genders, but sounds heavier.
- cada estudante – gender‑neutral in form, often used in more formal or inclusive language.
The original sentence uses the common pattern: female teacher, generic masculine for students.
- diz = “says” (3rd person singular of dizer, “to say”).
- que here is the conjunction “that”.
So diz que = “says that”.
In English, “that” is often optional:
- The teacher says (that) each student is responsible…
In Portuguese, the que is not optional in this structure. You must keep it:
- ✅ A professora diz que cada aluno é responsável…
- ❌ A professora diz cada aluno é responsável… (incorrect)
So que introduces the reported clause cada aluno é responsável pelo seu próprio estudo.
Cada (“each”) is always singular in Portuguese, just like in English:
- cada aluno é = “each student is”
- never cada alunos são
If you want a plural idea (“all the students”), you don’t use cada, you use something like:
- todos os alunos são responsáveis… = “all (the) students are responsible…”
Many adjectives in Portuguese do change with gender (e.g. aluno aplicado / aluna aplicada).
But adjectives ending in -vel (like responsável) are usually:
- the same form for masculine and feminine
- they only change for number (singular/plural)
So:
- o aluno é responsável
- a aluna é responsável
- os alunos são responsáveis
- as alunas são responsáveis
Only the plural adds -s: responsáveis.
In Portuguese, adjectives and verbs often have fixed prepositions that just have to be memorized.
For responsável, the usual pattern is:
- responsável por
- noun or gerund
Examples:
- responsável pelo projeto – responsible for the project
- responsável por organizar a reunião – responsible for organizing the meeting
So in this sentence we say:
- responsável pelo seu próprio estudo
not - ❌ responsável de
- ❌ responsável para
Even if in English we say “responsible for”, you must know/remember that in Portuguese it’s responsável por.
Pelo is a contraction of the preposition por and the masculine singular definite article o:
- por + o = pelo
So:
- por o estudo → pelo estudo = “for the study”
Other common contractions:
- por + a = pela (pela casa – for the house)
- por + os = pelos
- por + as = pelas
In this sentence:
- responsável por + o estudo → responsável pelo estudo
Yes, seu is context‑dependent and can be ambiguous on its own. It can mean:
- his
- her
- its
- your (formal singular or plural)
- their
In this sentence:
- cada aluno é responsável pelo seu próprio estudo
The most natural reading is:
- seu = “his/her own”, referring back to cada aluno.
Because cada aluno is singular and generic, seu is understood as “each student’s own”.
In other contexts, seu can be ambiguous, so speakers sometimes avoid it and say dele / dela / deles / delas to be clearer:
- o estudo dele – his study
- o estudo dela – her study
But here the context makes seu clear.
Literally:
- seu estudo = “his/her study” (or “their study”, etc.)
- seu próprio estudo = “his/her own study”
The word próprio adds emphasis on “own”, just like in English:
- “Each student is responsible for his/her study.”
- “Each student is responsible for his/her own study.” (stronger emphasis on personal responsibility)
So seu próprio isn’t grammatically necessary, but it reinforces the idea that the responsibility is personal, not shared.
In Portuguese, estudo can be:
- a countable noun – “a study” (a piece of research), or “studies” in the academic‑subject sense
- an uncountable / abstract noun – “study” as an activity or process.
Here it’s uncountable and abstract:
- o seu próprio estudo ≈ “your own studying / your own study habits / your own learning”
You could say os seus próprios estudos, but:
- o seu próprio estudo sounds more like the overall activity / responsibility of studying
- os seus próprios estudos can put more focus on specific courses or pieces of work
Both are possible, but the singular abstract estudo is very natural here.
The sentence:
- A professora diz que cada aluno é responsável pelo seu próprio estudo.
is perfectly natural in both European and Brazilian Portuguese.
Small notes:
- In speech, Brazilian Portuguese might be more likely (not obligatory) to drop the article with a proper name:
- A professora Ana diz… (PT/BR) vs sometimes Professora Ana diz… (BR), but here we don’t have a name, just a professora, so it’s the same.
- Pronunciation will differ, but the grammar and wording are fully acceptable in both varieties.
Responsável is pronounced roughly:
- European Portuguese: [ʁɨʃ-põ-za-vɛl] (with the typical EP vowel reduction and nasal -spon-)
- Brazilian Portuguese: [ʁes-põ-za-vew]
The accent mark ´ on responsável shows:
- Where the stress is: on -sá- → res‑pon‑sá‑vel
- That the vowel is open á (not the closed â sound).
Without the accent it would be an incorrect spelling (responsavel is wrong); the accent is part of the correct written form and guides stress and vowel quality.