Questions & Answers about Ved havet sitter bestefar på en gammel brygge og ser på bølgene.
Norwegian main clauses follow the V2 rule (verb‑second):
- The finite verb must be in the second position in the sentence.
- The first position can be the subject, an adverb, or a prepositional phrase.
In the sentence:
- Ved havet = first element (a place phrase)
- sitter = second element (the verb)
- bestefar = third element (the subject)
So Ved havet sitter bestefar is correct.
Ved havet bestefar sitter breaks the V2 rule, because the verb is no longer in second position, so it is ungrammatical in standard Norwegian.
You can also say Bestefar sitter ved havet, where:
- Bestefar (subject) is first
- sitter (verb) is second
- ved havet (place phrase) comes later
This also respects V2.
Yes, that sentence is correct too:
- Bestefar sitter ved havet på en gammel brygge.
The basic meaning (where Grandpa is and what he is doing) is the same, but the emphasis changes slightly:
Ved havet sitter bestefar på en gammel brygge
– Starts with ved havet, so it strongly emphasizes the location by the sea.Bestefar sitter ved havet på en gammel brygge
– Starts with bestefar, which is a more neutral word order focusing first on the person.
Both versions are natural; which one you choose depends on what you want to highlight first.