Breakdown of I lys av lysforurensningen velger vi annet observasjonssted.
Questions & Answers about I lys av lysforurensningen velger vi annet observasjonssted.
What does i lys av mean here?
I lys av is a fixed expression meaning in light of, considering, or in view of.
So I lys av lysforurensningen means something like considering the light pollution.
Literally, lys means light, but in this phrase you should learn the whole expression as one unit:
- i lys av = in light of / given / considering
It is a slightly formal expression.
Why is lys used twice in I lys av lysforurensningen?
The two instances of lys are doing different jobs:
- i lys av is an idiomatic expression
- lysforurensning is a compound noun meaning light pollution
So even though it may look repetitive, it is not accidental repetition. In English, In light of the light pollution... can also sound repetitive for the same reason.
Why is lysforurensningen in the definite form?
The ending -en makes lysforurensningen definite: the light pollution.
Compare:
- lysforurensning = light pollution / light pollution in general
- lysforurensningen = the light pollution / a specific, known case of light pollution
The sentence is referring to a particular light-pollution situation that is relevant in the context, so the definite form makes sense.
Why is the word order velger vi and not vi velger?
This is because Norwegian main clauses normally follow the V2 rule: the finite verb comes in the second position.
Here, the sentence begins with the prepositional phrase:
- I lys av lysforurensningen
Since that part comes first, the verb must come next:
- I lys av lysforurensningen velger vi ...
So the structure is:
- fronted phrase
- finite verb
- subject
Compare:
- Vi velger annet observasjonssted.
- I lys av lysforurensningen velger vi annet observasjonssted.
This is very common in Norwegian.
What does annet mean, and why is it annet instead of annen or andre?
Annet means another or a different here.
It changes form to agree with the noun it describes.
The noun observasjonssted is:
- singular
- neuter (et word)
So the correct form is:
- et annet observasjonssted
Compare the forms:
- en annen bok = another book
- et annet sted = another place
- andre bøker = other books
So annet is used because observasjonssted is a neuter singular noun.
Why is there no et before annet observasjonssted?
This is a very natural question, because many learners expect et annet observasjonssted.
In full, standard Bokmål, et annet observasjonssted is often the form many speakers would expect. The version without et can sound more compressed or formal, and some speakers may find it less natural in everyday speech.
So:
- et annet observasjonssted = a very clear, full form
- annet observasjonssted = shorter, more condensed wording
If you are learning and want the safest everyday version, et annet observasjonssted is a good choice.
Is observasjonssted a compound noun?
Yes. Observasjonssted is a compound noun:
- observasjon = observation
- sted = place/site
Together:
- observasjonssted = observation site / place for observation
Norwegian forms compound nouns very often, much more freely than English. English might write two words, but Norwegian often joins them into one.
Also, the final part of the compound usually determines the grammatical gender. Since sted is neuter, observasjonssted is also neuter:
- et observasjonssted
That is why the sentence uses annet.
Could you also say på grunn av lysforurensningen instead of i lys av lysforurensningen?
Yes, you could, but the nuance changes.
- på grunn av lysforurensningen = because of the light pollution
- i lys av lysforurensningen = in light of / considering the light pollution
På grunn av sounds more directly causal. I lys av sounds a bit more formal, reflective, or analytical, as if the decision is being made after taking the situation into account.
So both can work, but they are not exactly identical in tone.
What tense is velger, and can it describe a present decision?
Velger is the present tense of å velge = to choose.
In Norwegian, the present tense is often used for:
- current actions
- habits
- general statements
- decisions being made now
So here velger vi can mean:
- we choose
- we are choosing
- sometimes even we choose/will choose, depending on context
Norwegian often uses the present tense where English might choose either present continuous or a future expression.
Does this sentence sound formal?
Yes, somewhat.
The sentence sounds more formal or written because of:
- i lys av instead of a simpler phrase like på grunn av
- the somewhat compressed style of annet observasjonssted
A more everyday version might be:
- På grunn av lysforurensningen velger vi et annet observasjonssted.
The original sentence is still understandable, but it has a more official or report-like tone.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning NorwegianMaster Norwegian — from I lys av lysforurensningen velger vi annet observasjonssted to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions