Breakdown of Benkeforslaget kan godkjennes, gitt at flertallet støtter det.
Questions & Answers about Benkeforslaget kan godkjennes, gitt at flertallet støtter det.
What does benkeforslaget mean, and why is it one long word?
Benkeforslaget is a compound noun, which is very common in Norwegian.
It is made up of:
- benk = bench
- forslag = proposal
- -et = the definite ending
In political or meeting language, benkeforslag usually means a proposal made directly during the meeting, often “from the floor,” rather than submitted in advance.
So:
- et benkeforslag = a floor proposal / a proposal made during the meeting
- benkeforslaget = the floor proposal
Norwegian often joins nouns together into one word where English would use several words.
Why does the sentence use benkeforslaget and not et benkeforslag?
Because benkeforslaget is the definite form: the proposal rather than a proposal.
Compare:
- et benkeforslag = a floor proposal
- benkeforslaget = the floor proposal
The sentence is talking about a specific proposal that is already known in context, so the definite form is used.
What does kan godkjennes mean exactly?
Why is it godkjennes and not godkjenne?
Because godkjennes is a passive form.
The verb is:
- å godkjenne = to approve
Active:
- Flertallet godkjenner forslaget. = The majority approves the proposal.
Passive:
- Forslaget godkjennes. = The proposal is approved.
- Forslaget kan godkjennes. = The proposal can be approved.
In Norwegian, one common way to make the passive is by adding -s to the verb, especially in formal or written language.
So:
- godkjenne = approve
- godkjennes = be approved / is approved
Is godkjennes a present tense form or an infinitive?
In this sentence, it functions as an infinitive passive after kan.
After modal verbs like kan, skal, må, and vil, Norwegian normally uses the infinitive without å.
So:
- kan godkjenne = can approve
- kan godkjennes = can be approved
Even though -s passive forms can sometimes look like present-tense forms, here the structure after kan tells you it is the infinitive passive.
What does gitt at mean?
Gitt at means given that, provided that, or on condition that.
In this sentence, it introduces a condition:
- Benkeforslaget kan godkjennes, gitt at flertallet støtter det.
- The proposal can be approved, provided that the majority supports it.
This expression is somewhat formal. In everyday Norwegian, you might also see:
- hvis = if
- dersom = if
- forutsatt at = provided that
Why is there at after gitt?
Because gitt at works together as a fixed expression meaning given that / provided that.
You should learn it as a unit:
- gitt at ...
Other conjunction-like expressions in Norwegian also use at, for example:
- forutsatt at = provided that
- slik at = so that
So at is not optional here in standard usage.
What does flertallet mean, and why does it end in -et?
Flertallet means the majority.
The base noun is:
- et flertall = a majority
The definite form is:
- flertallet = the majority
The -et ending is the definite singular ending for many neuter nouns.
So:
- et flertall
- flertallet
Why is it støtter and not støtte?
Because støtter is the present tense form of the verb.
The verb is:
- å støtte = to support
Present tense:
- støtter = support / supports
Here the subject is flertallet (the majority), so:
- flertallet støtter det = the majority supports it
Compare:
- å støtte = to support
- flertallet støtter det = the majority supports it
What does det refer to?
Det refers back to benkeforslaget.
So:
- flertallet støtter det = the majority supports it
- and it = the floor proposal
Norwegian often uses det to refer to nouns that in English might be translated as it.
Why is the pronoun det used for benkeforslaget?
Because forslag is a neuter noun:
- et forslag = a proposal
Neuter nouns typically take the pronoun det.
So:
- et forslag
- forslaget
- det = it
Even though benkeforslaget is a compound noun, the grammatical gender comes from the final part, forslag, which is neuter.
Could the sentence also be written with hvis instead of gitt at?
Yes. A simpler version would be:
- Benkeforslaget kan godkjennes hvis flertallet støtter det.
This means almost the same thing: The proposal can be approved if the majority supports it.
The difference is mostly in tone:
- hvis = more neutral and common
- gitt at = more formal, a bit more like provided that
Why is there a comma before gitt at flertallet støtter det?
The comma separates the main statement from the following condition.
Main clause:
- Benkeforslaget kan godkjennes
Conditional phrase/clause:
- gitt at flertallet støtter det
In Norwegian, commas are often used to make sentence structure clearer, especially in formal writing. Even if punctuation rules can vary a little by style, the comma here is natural and helps show that the second part adds a condition.
Is this a very formal sentence?
Yes, it sounds fairly formal, especially because of:
- benkeforslaget — specialized meeting/political vocabulary
- godkjennes — passive form, common in formal writing
- gitt at — a formal conditional expression
A more everyday version might be:
- Benkeforslaget kan bli godkjent hvis flertallet støtter det.
That means essentially the same thing, but sounds a bit less formal and more conversational.
What is the basic sentence structure here?
The structure is:
- Subject: Benkeforslaget
- Modal verb: kan
- Passive infinitive: godkjennes
- Conditional clause: gitt at flertallet støtter det
So literally:
- The floor proposal
- can
- be approved, + provided that the majority supports it
- can
This is a useful pattern in Norwegian:
- [subject] kan [passive verb], gitt at [condition]
For example:
- Planen kan gjennomføres, gitt at alle er enige.
- The plan can be carried out, provided that everyone agrees.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning NorwegianMaster Norwegian — from Benkeforslaget kan godkjennes, gitt at flertallet støtter det to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions