Breakdown of Mater dicit colonam non solum magnae industriae, sed etiam magnae patientiae esse.
Questions & Answers about Mater dicit colonam non solum magnae industriae, sed etiam magnae patientiae esse.
Why is colonam in the accusative?
Because this sentence uses indirect statement after dicit.
In Latin, after verbs like dicit (says), the subject of the reported statement goes into the accusative, and the verb goes into the infinitive.
So in:
Mater dicit colonam ... esse
the person being talked about inside the reported statement is colonam, so it is accusative.
In English we say:
- Mother says that the female farmer is ...
But Latin does not use that here. Instead it uses:
- [accusative subject] + [infinitive verb]
So colonam esse = that the female farmer is.
What construction is dicit ... esse?
This is the accusative-and-infinitive construction, often called an indirect statement.
The pattern is:
- main verb of saying/thinking/perceiving
- accusative subject
- infinitive
Here:
- Mater = the subject of the main verb
- dicit = says
- colonam = accusative subject of the indirect statement
- esse = infinitive, to be
So literally the structure is:
- Mother says the female farmer to be ...
That sounds awkward in English, so we translate it as:
- Mother says that the female farmer is ...
Why is there no Latin word for that?
Because Latin usually does not use a conjunction like English that after verbs of saying, thinking, knowing, hearing, and so on when reporting a statement.
English:
- Mother says that the female farmer is ...
Latin:
- Mater dicit colonam ... esse
The idea of that is built into the accusative + infinitive construction. So the indirect statement itself does the job that that does in English.
Why are magnae industriae and magnae patientiae in the genitive?
They are examples of the genitive of description/quality.
Latin can express a quality by saying someone is of some quality:
- magnae industriae = of great industry / diligence
- magnae patientiae = of great patience
So the sentence does not literally say the woman is great diligence or is great patience. Instead it says she is of great diligence and of great patience.
This is a very natural Latin way to describe a person’s character.
Why is it magnae industriae and not magnam industriam?
Because industriae is not a direct object here. It is part of a genitive phrase of quality.
Compare:
- magnam industriam habet = she has great diligence
- here industriam is accusative because it is the object of habet
But in your sentence:
- est magnae industriae = she is of great diligence
Here the idea is descriptive, not an object. So Latin uses the genitive:
- industriae
- with agreeing adjective magnae
The same is true for magnae patientiae.
What does non solum ... sed etiam mean?
It is a very common paired expression meaning:
- not only ... but also
Here it links the two qualities:
- non solum magnae industriae
- sed etiam magnae patientiae
So the sense is:
- not only of great diligence, but also of great patience
Latin often uses this pair exactly where English would use not only ... but also.
Why is magnae repeated?
It is repeated because each genitive phrase stands on its own:
- magnae industriae
- magnae patientiae
Each adjective agrees with its noun in:
- gender: feminine
- number: singular
- case: genitive
Latin often repeats an adjective in parallel phrases like this, especially for clarity and balance.
It would be much less neat if the adjective were not repeated, since the sentence is carefully balancing two qualities.
What is the grammatical role of esse here?
Esse is the infinitive of sum, meaning to be.
In the indirect statement, it is the verb that goes with colonam:
- colonam ... esse = that the female farmer is ...
Everything between colonam and esse tells us what kind of person she is.
So the core of the reported statement is:
- colonam esse
and then Latin adds the descriptive genitives:
- colonam magnae industriae esse
- colonam magnae patientiae esse
Why does esse come at the end?
Because Latin word order is flexible, and infinitives—especially esse—often come at or near the end of the clause.
Placing esse at the end lets the sentence build up first:
- the reported subject: colonam
- the two qualities: non solum magnae industriae, sed etiam magnae patientiae
- then the verb: esse
This is a very normal Latin arrangement. English word order is much stricter, but Latin often saves the verb for the end.
Is mater part of the indirect statement too?
No. Mater belongs to the main clause.
Main clause:
- Mater dicit = Mother says
Indirect statement:
- colonam non solum magnae industriae, sed etiam magnae patientiae esse
So mater is the one doing the saying, while colonam is the subject inside what is being said.
Could magnae industriae and magnae patientiae be translated more naturally in English?
Yes. Grammatically, they mean:
- of great diligence
- of great patience
But idiomatic English might prefer something like:
- very hardworking
- very diligent
- very patient
So although the Latin uses noun phrases, English often switches to adjectives for smoother translation.
Still, for understanding the grammar, it is helpful to remember the more literal pattern:
- of great diligence
- of great patience
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Mater dicit colonam non solum magnae industriae, sed etiam magnae patientiae esse to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions