Breakdown of Discipuli bonam magistram imitari conantur, sed Lucia sola in scribendo excellit.
Questions & Answers about Discipuli bonam magistram imitari conantur, sed Lucia sola in scribendo excellit.
Why is discipuli the subject, and what case is it?
Discipuli is nominative plural, so it is the subject of conantur.
- discipulus = student, pupil
- discipuli = students / the students in the nominative plural
In this sentence, discipuli are the ones who are doing the trying.
Why is bonam magistram in the accusative?
Bonam magistram is the direct object of imitari.
Even though imitari looks passive in form, it is a deponent verb, so it has:
- passive-looking forms
- but an active meaning
So imitari means to imitate, and it still takes a normal direct object in the accusative.
That is why we get:
- bonam = accusative singular feminine
- magistram = accusative singular feminine
Together: bonam magistram = a/the good teacher as the thing being imitated.
Why is the verb imitari an infinitive here?
It is used as a complementary infinitive after conantur.
Latin often uses a verb like conor (try) with an infinitive:
- conantur imitari = they try to imitate
So conantur gives the main action (they try), and imitari completes the idea by telling us what they try to do.
Is conantur also a deponent verb?
Yes. Conantur comes from conor, conari, conatus sum, which is a deponent verb.
That means:
- it has passive forms
- but an active meaning
So conantur looks passive, but it means they try, not they are tried.
Formally, conantur is:
- 3rd person plural
- present tense
- indicative mood
What exactly does sola mean here?
Sola means alone or only.
It agrees with Lucia, so it is:
- nominative
- singular
- feminine
Because it modifies Lucia, the sense is:
- Lucia alone
- Lucia is the only one who...
So the contrast is that the students in general try to imitate the teacher, but Lucia alone stands out in writing.
Why is excellit singular when the sentence began with discipuli?
Because excellit belongs to a new clause with a different subject: Lucia.
The sentence has two parts joined by sed (but):
- Discipuli ... conantur
- sed Lucia sola ... excellit
So:
- conantur is plural because its subject is discipuli
- excellit is singular because its subject is Lucia
What is in scribendo? Why not just scribere?
In scribendo is an ablative gerund construction.
- scribendo is the gerund of scribere
- after in with the ablative, it often means in writing, at writing, or in the activity of writing
So in scribendo excellit means something like:
- she excels in writing
- she is outstanding at writing
Latin often prefers this kind of construction after in rather than using an infinitive.
What is a gerund, and how is scribendo formed?
A gerund is a verbal noun. It expresses the action of a verb in a noun-like way, similar to English writing in some contexts.
From scribere (to write), the gerund forms include things like:
- genitive: scribendi
- dative: scribendo
- accusative: scribendum (usually with a preposition)
- ablative: scribendo
Here we have in scribendo, where scribendo is ablative singular because it follows in.
Does sola mean the same thing as putting only before the verb in English?
Not exactly. Sola specifically modifies Lucia, not the verb.
So:
- Lucia sola excellit = Lucia alone excels
- not Lucia excels only
That distinction matters. The Latin is emphasizing who stands out, not limiting the action itself.
Why doesn’t Latin use a word for the or a here?
Classical Latin normally has no articles.
So a word like magistram can mean:
- a teacher
- the teacher
Context tells you which is most natural.
The same is true for discipuli:
- students
- the students
English requires an article more often than Latin does, but Latin usually leaves it unstated.
Why is the word order so different from English?
Latin word order is much more flexible because the endings show the grammatical roles.
For example:
- discipuli tells you who the subject is
- magistram tells you the object
- conantur tells you the main verb
- Lucia is the subject of excellit
Because the endings carry so much information, Latin can move words around for emphasis or style.
In this sentence, the order helps highlight the contrast:
- Discipuli ... conantur
- sed Lucia sola ... excellit
Why does bonam have to match magistram?
Because bonam is an adjective modifying magistram, and Latin adjectives must agree with the nouns they describe in:
- gender
- number
- case
So since magistram is:
- feminine
- singular
- accusative
the adjective must also be:
- feminine
- singular
- accusative
That gives bonam magistram.
What is the basic structure of the whole sentence?
It has two coordinated clauses joined by sed:
Discipuli bonam magistram imitari conantur
- subject: discipuli
- main verb: conantur
- infinitive complement: imitari
- object of imitari: bonam magistram
sed Lucia sola in scribendo excellit
- subject: Lucia
- modifier of subject: sola
- phrase showing area of excellence: in scribendo
- main verb: excellit
So the sentence moves from a general statement about the students to a contrasting statement about Lucia in particular.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Discipuli bonam magistram imitari conantur, sed Lucia sola in scribendo excellit to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions