Breakdown of Mater dicit victoriam sine superbia meliorem esse, quia post cladem saepe longa fuga sequitur.
Questions & Answers about Mater dicit victoriam sine superbia meliorem esse, quia post cladem saepe longa fuga sequitur.
Why is victoriam in the accusative?
Because this sentence uses an indirect statement after dicit.
In Latin, after verbs of saying, thinking, knowing, and perceiving, the subject of the reported statement goes into the accusative, and the verb goes into the infinitive.
So in:
Mater dicit victoriam sine superbia meliorem esse
the reported statement is:
victoriam ... meliorem esse = that victory ... is better
Here, victoriam is the subject of that indirect statement, so it is accusative.
Why is esse used here?
Esse is the present infinitive of sum, meaning to be.
In an indirect statement, Latin normally uses:
- accusative subject
- infinitive verb
So:
- victoriam = the subject of the indirect statement
- esse = the verb of the indirect statement
Literally, Latin says something like:
Mother says victory without arrogance to be better
but natural English becomes:
Mother says that victory without arrogance is better.
Why is it meliorem and not melior?
Because meliorem agrees with victoriam.
- victoriam is feminine accusative singular
- so the adjective describing it must also be feminine accusative singular
The adjective is the comparative form of bonus:
- bonus = good
- melior = better
- meliorem = better, in the accusative singular
So victoriam ... meliorem esse means that victory is better.
Why is there no word for than with meliorem?
Because Latin comparatives do not always need an explicit comparison.
Here meliorem simply means better, with the comparison understood from the context. The idea is something like:
- better in a general sense
- or better than victory with arrogance
Latin often leaves that unstated when it is obvious.
If Latin wanted to state the comparison explicitly, it could use quam or the ablative of comparison, but it does not have to.
What case is superbia, and why?
Superbia is ablative singular because it follows the preposition sine.
Sine means without, and it takes the ablative.
So:
- sine superbia = without arrogance / without pride
This is a very common thing to memorize with prepositions: each Latin preposition regularly takes a particular case.
What exactly does sine superbia modify?
It goes with victoriam and describes the kind of victory being discussed.
So the phrase means:
- victory without arrogance
- victory free from pride
In other words, the mother is not talking about victory in general only, but specifically about a humble or unboastful victory.
Why is cladem accusative?
Because it follows the preposition post.
Post means after, and it takes the accusative case.
So:
- post cladem = after defeat / after a disaster
The dictionary form is clades, but after post it becomes cladem.
Why is it longa fuga and not longam fugam?
Because longa fuga is the subject of sequitur.
In the clause:
quia post cladem saepe longa fuga sequitur
the thing that follows is a long flight.
So:
- fuga is nominative singular
- longa agrees with fuga in nominative singular feminine
That is why both are nominative, not accusative.
Why does sequitur look passive if the meaning is active?
Because sequitur is a deponent verb.
Deponent verbs:
- have passive-looking forms
- but active meanings
So sequitur looks like is followed, but it actually means:
- follows
- comes after
Here:
longa fuga sequitur = a long flight follows
This is a very common point of confusion for English speakers.
What is the subject of sequitur?
The subject is longa fuga.
Even though English often says there follows a long flight or a long flight follows, Latin simply makes fuga the nominative subject.
So the structure is:
- longa fuga = subject
- sequitur = verb
- post cladem = adverbial phrase, telling when/after what
Why is saepe placed where it is?
Saepe is an adverb meaning often, and Latin adverbs have fairly flexible placement.
Here it modifies sequitur:
post cladem saepe longa fuga sequitur
= after defeat, a long flight often follows
Latin word order is not as fixed as English word order, so saepe can stand in a natural position without changing the basic meaning.
Why is the word order so different from English?
Because Latin uses case endings much more than word order to show grammatical relationships.
For example:
- victoriam is accusative, so we know its role from the ending
- superbia is ablative after sine
- fuga is nominative, so it is the subject of sequitur
That means Latin can arrange words more freely for emphasis, rhythm, or style.
For instance, placing meliorem esse near the end gives a neat finish to the indirect statement, and longa fuga before sequitur helps highlight what follows after defeat.
Why is quia followed by sequitur in the indicative, not the subjunctive?
Because quia here introduces a straightforward reason clause:
because after defeat a long flight often follows
When Latin gives a reason as a real fact from the speaker’s point of view, it commonly uses the indicative.
So sequitur is just normal present indicative:
- quia = because
- sequitur = follows
There is no need for the subjunctive here.
What are the basic dictionary forms of the main words here?
A learner often wants to identify the forms back to their dictionary entries. Here are the main ones:
- mater from mater, matris = mother
- dicit from dico, dicere, dixi, dictum = say
- victoriam from victoria, victoriae = victory
- superbia from superbia, superbiae = arrogance, pride
- meliorem from melior, melius = better
- esse from sum, esse, fui = be
- quia = because
- cladem from clades, cladis = disaster, defeat
- saepe = often
- longa from longus, longa, longum = long
- fuga from fuga, fugae = flight, escape
- sequitur from sequor, sequi, secutus sum = follow
Seeing the dictionary form often makes the case and syntax much easier to understand.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Mater dicit victoriam sine superbia meliorem esse, quia post cladem saepe longa fuga sequitur to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions