Breakdown of Soror quoque salire vult, sed pater eam monet ne ad flammam propius accedat.
Questions & Answers about Soror quoque salire vult, sed pater eam monet ne ad flammam propius accedat.
Why is quoque placed after soror instead of before it?
In Latin, quoque means also or too, and it usually comes after the word it emphasizes.
So:
- soror quoque = the sister too / the sister also
This is different from English, where also often comes before the word or later in the sentence.
A useful habit is:
- X quoque = X too
So here the sentence is emphasizing that the sister also wants to jump.
Why is salire in the infinitive?
Because it depends on vult.
- vult = she wants
- salire = to jump
Latin often uses the infinitive after verbs of wanting, being able, beginning, etc., just as English does:
- vult salire = she wants to jump
So salire is not a finite verb here; it is the infinitive complement of vult.
Who is the subject of vult?
The subject is soror.
So:
- soror ... vult = the sister wants
Latin often leaves out subject pronouns when they are not needed, because the verb ending already helps identify the person. Here vult is he/she/it wants, and soror tells us it is she, namely the sister.
What is the function of eam?
Eam is the accusative singular feminine form of ea, id, meaning her.
It is the direct object of monet:
- pater eam monet = the father warns/advises her
So the father is warning her, that is, the sister.
Why do we use eam instead of ea?
Because monet takes a direct object, and a direct object must be in the accusative case.
The forms are:
- ea = she / she herself or that woman in the nominative
- eam = her in the accusative
Since the father is warning her, not she, Latin uses eam.
What does monet mean here, and how is it constructed?
Monet comes from moneo, monere, which can mean warn, advise, remind, depending on context.
Here it means something like:
- warns
- advises
The construction is:
- monet + person in the accusative + ne-clause
So:
- pater eam monet ne ... accedat
= the father warns her not to approach ...
This is a very common Latin pattern.
Why is there a ne in the sentence?
Here ne means that ... not or more naturally in English, simply not in a clause after a verb like warn or advise.
So:
- monet ne accedat = warns [her] not to approach
This is different from non.
- non usually negates a word or statement directly
- ne is commonly used in certain subordinate clauses, especially with commands, wishes, fears, and warning/advising constructions
So after monet, Latin uses ne to introduce the negative idea.
Why is accedat in the subjunctive?
Because it is in a subordinate clause introduced by ne after monet.
The pattern is:
- moneo aliquem ne + subjunctive
- warn someone not to ...
So:
- ne ... accedat = not to approach
This is not a main-statement verb. It is part of the warning clause, and Latin regularly uses the subjunctive in this construction.
Why is it accedat and not accedit?
Because accedit would be indicative, meaning something like she approaches.
But here Latin does not mean the father warns her, and she approaches. Instead, it means:
- the father warns her not to approach
That requires the subjunctive:
- accedat
So the difference is grammatical as well as logical:
- accedit = indicative statement
- accedat = subjunctive in the dependent ne clause
What does propius mean, and why is it not propius ad flammam with a different form?
Propius means nearer or too near / closer depending on context. Here it means closer.
It is the comparative form used adverbially:
- prope = near
- propius = nearer / more closely
So:
- propius accedat = approach more closely / come nearer
It modifies the verb accedat, so it works as an adverb.
Why is flammam in the accusative?
Because it follows the preposition ad, and ad takes the accusative case.
- ad flammam = toward the flame / to the flame
So the pattern is:
- ad + accusative
That is why we have flammam, not flamma.
What exactly does ad flammam propius accedat mean?
Literally, it means:
- approach nearer to the flame
More natural English would be:
- go any closer to the flame
- come too close to the flame
- approach the flame more closely
The idea is that the father is warning her not to move closer to the fire.
Why is sed used here?
Sed means but.
It marks a contrast between the two parts of the sentence:
- Soror quoque salire vult = The sister also wants to jump
- sed pater eam monet ... = but her father warns her ...
So the contrast is:
- she wants to do something
- but her father intervenes
Is there any reason Latin repeats the subject with pater instead of using a pronoun?
Yes. Latin often names the noun clearly when introducing a new subject or creating contrast.
In the first clause, the subject is soror. In the second, the subject changes to pater. Using pater makes that shift clear:
- soror ... vult
- sed pater ... monet
If Latin had used only the verb without pater, the reader might need more context to know who is doing the warning.
Why is the verb in the last clause singular if soror and pater are both in the sentence?
Because accedat belongs to the ne clause, and its implied subject is still she, the sister, not both people.
So the structure is:
- pater eam monet = the father warns her
- ne ... accedat = that she not approach
Even though both soror and pater appear in the sentence, the person who would be approaching the flame is only her. Therefore the verb is singular.
How can I see the overall structure of the sentence more clearly?
A good way is to divide it into parts:
Soror quoque salire vult
= The sister also wants to jumpsed pater eam monet
= but the father warns herne ad flammam propius accedat
= not to go closer to the flame
So the whole sentence is built like this:
- main clause
- sed
- main clause
- dependent ne-clause after monet
That structure is very common in Latin prose.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Soror quoque salire vult, sed pater eam monet ne ad flammam propius accedat to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods.
- ✓ Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓ Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓ Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions