Breakdown of komatta toki ha, hitori de kangaenaide tomodati ni tayotte ii.
Questions & Answers about komatta toki ha, hitori de kangaenaide tomodati ni tayotte ii.
Why is it 困ったとき and not 困るとき?
困ったとき uses the past form 困った before とき to mean when you are in trouble / when a problem has already come up.
In Japanese, the tense before とき often shows whether the situation is already true at that time.
- 困ったとき = when you’re already troubled
- 困るとき = when you get troubled / when trouble happens
For this kind of advice sentence, 困ったとき sounds more natural.
What does the は after とき do?
Why is 一人 followed by で?
Here, で shows the manner or condition in which the action is done.
So:
- 一人で考える = to think by yourself / to think alone
The で is not marking a place here. It is marking how the thinking is being done.
What exactly does 考えないで mean here?
考えないで is the negative て-form of 考える.
It can mean:
- don’t think ... and then ...
- without thinking ...
- instead of thinking ...
In this sentence, it works very naturally as:
- don’t keep thinking about it by yourself; rely on your friends instead
So it is connected to the next action, not just a standalone command.
Is 考えないで a strong command?
Not especially. It is much softer than a blunt imperative like 考えるな.
Because it is followed by advice about what to do instead, it sounds more supportive than forceful. The nuance is closer to:
- Don’t try to handle it all alone
- Try not to think it through by yourself
rather than a harsh Don’t think!
Why is it 友達に頼って and not 友達を頼って?
Because 頼る normally uses に for the person or thing you rely on.
The standard pattern is:
- 人に頼る = rely on a person
- 友達に頼る = rely on friends
So 友達に頼って is the natural form here.
What nuance does 頼る have in this sentence?
Shouldn’t it be 頼ってもいい instead of 頼っていい?
The full standard pattern for permission is てもいい:
- 頼ってもいい = it’s okay to rely on them
However, in casual speech and writing, the も is often omitted:
- 頼っていい
That shorter version is very common and still means it’s okay to rely on .... The version with も sounds a little more explicit or textbook-like.
Where is the subject in this sentence?
It is omitted, which is very normal in Japanese.
The sentence is understood as advice aimed at:
- you
- or people in general
Japanese often leaves out subjects when they are obvious from context. English usually needs to say you, but Japanese does not.
Is 困ったとき an example of a clause modifying a noun?
Are the spaces in the sentence normal Japanese writing?
No. The spaces are there to help learners read the sentence.
A normal written version would usually be:
困ったときは、一人で考えないで友達に頼っていい。
Japanese normally does not put spaces between words the way English does.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning JapaneseMaster Japanese — from komatta toki ha, hitori de kangaenaide tomodati ni tayotte ii to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions