Breakdown of nattou to umebosi ha konomi ga wakaremasu ga, watasi ha dotira mo suki desu.
Questions & Answers about nattou to umebosi ha konomi ga wakaremasu ga, watasi ha dotira mo suki desu.
Why is と used between 納豆 and 梅干し?
Why is は attached to the whole phrase 納豆と梅干し?
What does 好みが分かれます mean literally?
Is 分かれます the same as 分かります or わかる?
No. They are different words, even though they sound similar.
- 分かる(わかる) = to understand
- 分かれる(わかれる) = to split / be divided
Here it is 分かれる, not 分かる.
So 好みが分かれます does not mean preferences understand anything; it means preferences are divided.
Why is が used in 好みが分かれます?
In 好みが分かれます, が marks 好み as the grammatical subject of 分かれます.
The idea is:
- 好み = preferences/tastes
- が分かれます = split / are divided
So the thing that is doing the splitting grammatically is 好み.
Even though 納豆と梅干しは is the topic, the inner subject of the statement is still 好み.
What does the が in 分かれますが mean? Is it the same が?
This が is a different use of が. Here it means but or although.
So:
- 好みが分かれますが = tastes are divided, but...
Japanese often uses が to connect two clauses in a softer way than a strong English but. It can sound smoother and less blunt.
So in this sentence, the speaker says: These foods divide opinion, but I like both.
Why is 私 included? Couldn't it be omitted?
Yes, 私 could be omitted if the context already makes it clear who is speaking.
For example, どちらも好きです by itself can already mean I like both.
But 私は is included here for contrast: As for me, I like both.
That fits well after ...but..., because the speaker is contrasting their own opinion with the general situation.
How does どちらも mean both?
By itself, どちら means which one or which of the two.
When you add も, it changes the meaning to both.
So:
- どちら = which of the two?
- どちらも = both
This works because the sentence is talking about exactly two things: 納豆 and 梅干し.
Why use どちらも instead of 両方?
Why is it 好きです instead of a verb meaning like?
In Japanese, 好き is not a normal verb. It is a na-adjective / adjectival noun meaning liked or pleasant.
So どちらも好きです literally works more like: both are liked (by me)
That is why Japanese does not always match English grammar word-for-word here. English uses the verb like, but Japanese often uses 好き.
Why isn't there a particle after どちらも?
The も is doing the particle job here.
You can think of どちらも as a set phrase meaning both of them too / both of them. The object marker that might appear in other sentences is not needed separately here.
So 私はどちらも好きです is perfectly natural and means: I like both.
Could I say どっちも好きです instead?
Yes. どっち is a more casual version of どちら.
So:
- どちらも好きです = more neutral/polite
- どっちも好きです = more casual
Since this sentence uses polite です/ます style, どちらも matches the tone better.
Are the spaces in the sentence normal Japanese writing?
No. Standard Japanese is usually written without spaces between words.
So the sentence would normally appear as:
納豆と梅干しは好みが分かれますが、私はどちらも好きです。
Spaces are often added in teaching materials to make the structure easier for learners to see.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning JapaneseMaster Japanese — from nattou to umebosi ha konomi ga wakaremasu ga, watasi ha dotira mo suki desu to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions