Breakdown of In der Suppe sind Lauch und Brokkoli, deshalb riecht die Küche schon gut.
Questions & Answers about In der Suppe sind Lauch und Brokkoli, deshalb riecht die Küche schon gut.
Why is it In der Suppe and not In die Suppe?
Because this sentence describes location, not movement.
- in + dative = being in something
- in + accusative = going into something
Here, the leek and broccoli are already in the soup, so German uses the dative:
- in der Suppe = in the soup
Since die Suppe is feminine, its dative form is der Suppe.
Why does the sentence start with In der Suppe sind ... instead of Lauch und Brokkoli sind in der Suppe?
German often puts the topic or the most important information first. Both of these are correct:
- In der Suppe sind Lauch und Brokkoli.
- Lauch und Brokkoli sind in der Suppe.
When In der Suppe comes first, the verb must still stay in second position in a main clause. So the order becomes:
- In der Suppe = position 1
- sind = position 2
- Lauch und Brokkoli = subject after the verb
This is a very common German word-order pattern.
Why is it sind and not ist?
Because the subject is Lauch und Brokkoli, which is plural.
Even though Suppe is singular, it is not the subject here. The subject is the thing that matches the verb:
- Lauch und Brokkoli → plural
- therefore sind
So the structure is basically:
- In der Suppe = location
- sind = verb
- Lauch und Brokkoli = subject
Why are Lauch and Brokkoli used without articles?
In German, ingredients and foods are often named without articles when speaking generally or listing what something contains.
So:
- In der Suppe sind Lauch und Brokkoli
means something like - There is leek and broccoli in the soup / The soup contains leek and broccoli
This is similar to using food words as general substances.
You could use articles in other contexts, but it would change the feel:
- der Lauch = the leek
- ein Lauch = a leek
Here, the article-less form sounds natural for ingredients.
What exactly does Lauch mean here?
Lauch usually means leek.
In cooking contexts, it refers to the vegetable as an ingredient, so English may translate it simply as leek or leeks, depending on the style of translation. German often leaves this kind of noun in a more general, uncountable-like form when talking about ingredients.
Why is there a comma before deshalb?
Because deshalb here connects two main clauses:
- In der Suppe sind Lauch und Brokkoli
- deshalb riecht die Küche schon gut
In German, two independent main clauses are often separated by a comma, especially when linked by a word like deshalb, daher, trotzdem, etc.
So the comma helps mark the boundary between the two full clauses.
Why is it deshalb riecht die Küche and not deshalb die Küche riecht?
Because deshalb is not a subordinating conjunction like weil. It is an adverb that takes the first position in the clause, and then the verb must come second.
So the order is:
- deshalb = position 1
- riecht = position 2
- die Küche = subject
This is standard German main-clause word order.
Compare:
- Deshalb riecht die Küche schon gut.
- Die Küche riecht deshalb schon gut.
Both are possible, but the first one emphasizes the cause-effect connection more clearly.
What is the difference between deshalb and weil?
Both can express because, but they work differently.
- deshalb = therefore / that’s why / for that reason
- weil = because
With deshalb, you have a main clause word order:
- In der Suppe sind Lauch und Brokkoli, deshalb riecht die Küche schon gut.
With weil, the second clause becomes a subordinate clause, so the verb goes to the end:
- Die Küche riecht schon gut, weil in der Suppe Lauch und Brokkoli sind.
So deshalb focuses more on the result, while weil directly introduces the reason.
What does schon mean here?
Here schon means already.
So:
- Die Küche riecht schon gut = The kitchen already smells good
It suggests that even now, perhaps before the food is finished, the smell is pleasant.
In German, schon is very common and can have several meanings depending on context, but here already is the natural one.
Why does die Küche riecht gut mean the kitchen smells good? The kitchen itself isn’t producing the smell, right?
Right — this is a natural way of speaking in both German and English.
- Die Küche riecht gut literally means the kitchen smells good
- It really means that the kitchen has a pleasant smell or smells nice because of the cooking
German often uses places as the subject with riechen:
- Das Zimmer riecht nach Rauch. = The room smells like smoke.
- Die Küche riecht gut. = The kitchen smells good.
So it does not mean the kitchen itself is the source in a strict physical sense; it means the smell in that place is pleasant.
Can riechen be used in other ways too?
Yes. Riechen is a very useful verb and can be used in a few common patterns:
Something smells a certain way
- Die Küche riecht gut. = The kitchen smells good.
Something smells like something
- Die Küche riecht nach Suppe. = The kitchen smells like soup.
Someone smells something
- Ich rieche die Suppe. = I smell the soup.
So riechen can be either:
- intransitive = to smell
- transitive = to smell something
Could I also say Es sind Lauch und Brokkoli in der Suppe?
Yes, that is possible, but it sounds a bit different.
In der Suppe sind Lauch und Brokkoli.
is a neutral, natural way to say what the soup contains.Es sind Lauch und Brokkoli in der Suppe.
is also grammatical, but less straightforward and often feels more like spoken emphasis or a different information structure.
For a learner, In der Suppe sind Lauch und Brokkoli is the better model to copy.
Is this sentence natural everyday German?
Yes, it is natural and understandable.
It sounds like everyday spoken or written German, especially if someone is describing what is in the soup and reacting to the smell.
A very close everyday alternative might be:
- In der Suppe sind Lauch und Brokkoli, deshalb riecht es in der Küche schon gut.
That version shifts the focus slightly to it smells good in the kitchen, but your original sentence is still perfectly natural.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning GermanMaster German — from In der Suppe sind Lauch und Brokkoli, deshalb riecht die Küche schon gut to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions