Breakdown of Wir können die Aufgabe lösen, ohne den Taschenrechner zu benutzen, wenn wir ruhig nachdenken.
Questions & Answers about Wir können die Aufgabe lösen, ohne den Taschenrechner zu benutzen, wenn wir ruhig nachdenken.
Why does the sentence use both können and lösen?
This is a standard modal verb + infinitive pattern.
- können is the conjugated modal verb: wir können
- lösen is the main action verb in the infinitive, placed at the end of the main clause
So:
- Wir können die Aufgabe lösen. = We can solve the task/problem.
This is very similar to English can solve.
Why is it die Aufgabe?
Because die Aufgabe is the direct object of lösen.
The verb lösen takes an accusative object: you solve something.
- nominative: die Aufgabe
- accusative: die Aufgabe
Since Aufgabe is feminine singular, the article stays die in both nominative and accusative, so the form does not change here.
What does ohne ... zu + infinitive mean?
This structure means without doing something.
In the sentence:
- ohne den Taschenrechner zu benutzen = without using the calculator
It is a very common German pattern:
- ohne zu warten = without waiting
- ohne nachzudenken = without thinking
- ohne ihn zu fragen = without asking him
So ohne ... zu introduces an infinitive clause that describes something not being done.
Why is there no wir inside ohne den Taschenrechner zu benutzen?
Because the subject is understood to be the same as in the main clause.
Here, wir are the ones who können, and also the ones who would benutzen. German usually does not repeat the subject in an ohne ... zu clause when it is the same subject.
So:
- Wir können die Aufgabe lösen, ohne den Taschenrechner zu benutzen.
naturally means:
- We can solve the problem without using the calculator.
If the subject were different, German would often use a different structure, for example ohne dass ...
Why is it den Taschenrechner?
Because Taschenrechner is masculine, and here it is in the accusative.
That happens because benutzen takes a direct object in the accusative:
- den Taschenrechner benutzen = to use the calculator
So:
- nominative: der Taschenrechner
- accusative: den Taschenrechner
This is a good form to notice, because unlike die Aufgabe, the article does change here.
Why is zu used with benutzen, but not with lösen?
Because these are two different constructions.
After a modal verb like können, German uses a bare infinitive:
- Wir können die Aufgabe lösen.
- not Wir können die Aufgabe zu lösen
In an ohne ... zu infinitive clause, German does use zu:
- ohne den Taschenrechner zu benutzen
So:
- können + infinitive → no zu
- ohne ... zu + infinitive → zu is required
Why are there commas in this sentence?
There are commas for two reasons.
First, the ohne ... zu infinitive clause is set off with a comma:
- ..., ohne den Taschenrechner zu benutzen, ...
Second, the wenn clause is a subordinate clause, and subordinate clauses are separated by commas in German:
- ..., wenn wir ruhig nachdenken.
German uses commas more consistently than English in structures like these, so comma placement is something learners need to pay attention to.
Why is nachdenken at the end of the wenn clause?
Because wenn introduces a subordinate clause, and in German subordinate clauses send the conjugated verb to the end.
So:
- main clause: Wir denken ruhig nach.
- subordinate clause: wenn wir ruhig nachdenken
That final position is normal after wenn, weil, dass, obwohl, and many other subordinating conjunctions.
What does wenn mean here: if or when?
Wenn can mean either if or when, depending on context.
In this sentence, it is most naturally understood as if or when/whenever in a general sense:
- if we think calmly
- when we think calmly
- whenever we think calmly
English usually chooses one, but German wenn often covers both kinds of idea. If the sentence is presenting a condition, English often prefers if.
What does ruhig mean here?
Here ruhig means something like calmly, carefully, or without panicking.
So ruhig nachdenken is not mainly about being physically quiet. It means thinking in a calm, composed way.
This is a very common use of ruhig in German. It often carries the idea of take it easy or just stay calm.
Can the wenn clause come first?
Yes. German can move the subordinate clause to the front:
- Wenn wir ruhig nachdenken, können wir die Aufgabe lösen, ohne den Taschenrechner zu benutzen.
That is completely natural.
Notice what happens in the main clause after the fronted wenn clause:
- ..., können wir ...
The verb können comes before the subject wir because the first position in the sentence is already occupied by the whole wenn clause.
Why is nachdenken one word here, even though I have seen wir denken nach?
Because nachdenken is a separable verb.
Its basic infinitive is:
- nachdenken
But in a normal main clause, the prefix separates:
- Wir denken nach.
In a subordinate clause or infinitive form, it stays together:
- wenn wir nachdenken
- nachzudenken
So the sentence is showing the unsplit form because nachdenken is at the end of a subordinate clause.
Could I also say ohne einen Taschenrechner zu benutzen?
Yes. That would also be grammatical, but it changes the nuance slightly.
- ohne den Taschenrechner zu benutzen = without using the calculator
- ohne einen Taschenrechner zu benutzen = without using a/any calculator
The original sentence sounds like it is referring to the calculator as a known or contextually relevant object. Using einen makes it more indefinite.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning GermanMaster German — from Wir können die Aufgabe lösen, ohne den Taschenrechner zu benutzen, wenn wir ruhig nachdenken to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions