Im Ehrenamt hat für uns die Hilfe für andere Vorrang vor persönlichen Wünschen.

Elon.io is an online learning platform
We have an entire course teaching German grammar and vocabulary.

Start learning German now

Questions & Answers about Im Ehrenamt hat für uns die Hilfe für andere Vorrang vor persönlichen Wünschen.

What exactly does Im Ehrenamt mean? Is Ehrenamt just “volunteering”?

Ehrenamt literally combines Ehre (honour) + Amt (office/position). It means:

  • an unpaid, usually officially recognized role (e.g. volunteer firefighter, board member of a club, youth coach)
  • often with some responsibility or function inside an organization

Im Ehrenamt = “in (the context of) voluntary service / honorary office / volunteer work”.

It’s not just any casual volunteering; it suggests a more structured role than simply doing something helpful once in a while.

Why is it Im Ehrenamt and not In dem Ehrenamt?

Im is the standard contraction of in dem:

  • in + dem (dative, neuter singular)im

Because Ehrenamt is neuter (das Ehrenamt) and the preposition in here expresses location (in volunteer work, not movement into it), it takes the dative:

  • in dem Ehrenamt → contracted to im Ehrenamt

Using in dem Ehrenamt is grammatically correct but sounds overly heavy in normal speech here; im Ehrenamt is what native speakers naturally say.

Why does the verb hat come right after Im Ehrenamt instead of after the subject?

German main clauses follow the verb-second (V2) rule:

  • The finite verb (here: hat) must be in second position.
  • “Second” means: after the first element, not necessarily after the subject.

In this sentence:

  1. Im Ehrenamt = first element (a prepositional phrase)
  2. hat = verb in second position
  3. für uns die Hilfe für andere Vorrang vor persönlichen Wünschen = the rest of the clause, including the subject

So the subject die Hilfe für andere is not obliged to stand right after the verb; it just needs to be somewhere after the verb. This word order is completely normal German.

Who is the subject of the sentence, and why is it hat (singular)?

The subject is die Hilfe für andere:

  • Hilfe is feminine: die Hilfe
  • In the nominative singular, it is die Hilfe
  • The extra für andere just describes what kind of help: “help for others”

Because the subject is singular, the verb must be hat (3rd person singular of haben):

  • die Hilfe … hat Vorrang
    (the help … has priority)

So:

  • Subject: die Hilfe für andere
  • Verb: hat
  • Object/predicate noun: Vorrang (vor persönlichen Wünschen)
What does für uns mean here, and which case is uns?

Für uns means “for us / as far as we are concerned / in our view”.

Grammatically:

  • für always takes the accusative
  • wiruns in the accusative

So:

  • Preposition: für
  • Case: accusative
  • Pronoun form: uns

Functionally, für uns adds the nuance: “according to our values / from our perspective”.

How is die Hilfe für andere put together, and why is it andere and not anderen?

Structure:

  • die Hilfe = the help (feminine nominative singular, the subject)
  • für andere = for others

für always takes the accusative, so we need andere in the accusative plural without article.

Adjective/pronoun ending here:

  • No article (like die / meine etc.)
  • Plural, accusative → ending is -e

Hence:

  • für andere (for others) – correct
  • für anderen – would be wrong here

There’s no article because it’s general: “for other people” in general, not specific, known others.

Could I say anderen helfen instead of die Hilfe für andere? Is there a difference?

Yes, you could phrase it differently:

  • Im Ehrenamt ist es für uns wichtiger, anderen zu helfen als persönliche Wünsche zu erfüllen.

The difference is mainly style and grammar, not meaning:

  • die Hilfe für andere
    noun phrase (help for others), more formal/abstract
  • anderen helfen / anderen zu helfen
    verb phrase (to help others), more direct and a bit more conversational

The original sentence uses a nominalisation (die Hilfe) so that it can fit neatly into the pattern X hat Vorrang vor Y (X has priority over Y).

What does the expression Vorrang haben vor … mean exactly?

Vorrang haben vor X is a fixed expression meaning:

  • to take precedence over X
  • to have priority over X
  • to be more important than X

In the sentence:

  • die Hilfe für andere = what has priority
  • Vorrang = the priority
  • vor persönlichen Wünschen = over personal wishes

You could paraphrase:

  • Im Ehrenamt ist die Hilfe für andere für uns wichtiger als persönliche Wünsche.

So hat … Vorrang vor …ist … wichtiger als ….

Why is it vor persönlichen Wünschen and not vor persönliche Wünsche?

The preposition vor is a two-way preposition; it can take either:

  • dative (location / state, “in front of, before, over” in an abstract sense)
  • accusative (direction / movement towards)

Here it expresses an abstract priority relationship, not movement:

  • one thing has precedence over another → that’s a state, so dative

Thus:

  • vor
    • dative pluralvor persönlichen Wünschen
  • Wünschen is dative plural of Wünsche

Using vor persönliche Wünsche (accusative) would be incorrect in this meaning.

Why does the adjective end in -en in persönlichen Wünschen?

persönlichen is an adjective modifying Wünschen.

We have:

  • Preposition: vor → here with dative
  • Number: plural (Wünsche = wishes)
  • Noun in dative plural: (den) Wünschen

The adjective ending rules say:

  • In the dative plural, adjectives always take -en, regardless of whether there is an article or not.

So:

  • vor persönlichen Wünschen = correct
  • vor persönliche Wünschen = wrong
  • vor persönlichen den Wünschen = also wrong word order; den persönlichen Wünschen would be okay but redundant here

Pattern: dative plural → -en on adjectives.

Why is the noun Wünschen with -en at the end, and not just Wünsche?

The base plural form is die Wünsche (nominative/accusative).

In the dative plural, most German nouns add -n (if they don’t already end in -n or -s):

  • Nominative plural: die Wünsche
  • Dative plural: den Wünschen

Since vor is followed by the dative here, we need the dative plural form:

  • vor … Wünschen

So the -en on Wünschen is the dative plural ending, not just a random variation.

Could the word order be different, for example Für uns hat im Ehrenamt die Hilfe für andere Vorrang vor persönlichen Wünschen?

Yes, German allows some flexibility in word order as long as the finite verb stays in second position.

Alternative versions:

  • Für uns hat im Ehrenamt die Hilfe für andere Vorrang vor persönlichen Wünschen.
  • Die Hilfe für andere hat im Ehrenamt für uns Vorrang vor persönlichen Wünschen.
  • Im Ehrenamt hat die Hilfe für andere für uns Vorrang vor persönlichen Wünschen.

All are grammatical, but the focus changes slightly:

  • Starting with Für uns emphasizes our perspective.
  • Starting with Die Hilfe für andere emphasizes the help for others.
  • The original Im Ehrenamt hat … emphasizes the context of voluntary work first.

The verb hat must remain the second element in each version.