Breakdown of Statt dass der Chor heute im Saal singt, proben wir draußen im Hof, weil es so warm ist.
Questions & Answers about Statt dass der Chor heute im Saal singt, proben wir draußen im Hof, weil es so warm ist.
In German, statt by itself is a preposition and must be followed by a noun(-phrase), a pronoun, or an infinitive construction, not by a full clause with a finite verb.
- Correct with a noun:
- Statt des Chores singen wir. – Instead of the choir, we sing.
- Correct with an infinitive (same subject):
- Statt im Saal zu singen, proben wir im Hof.
But as soon as you want a full clause with its own subject and a conjugated verb, you need statt dass (or anstatt dass) as a conjunction:
- Statt dass der Chor heute im Saal singt, proben wir draußen im Hof.
So statt der Chor … singt is ungrammatical; you must use statt dass before a finite clause.
Yes, you can say anstatt dass der Chor heute im Saal singt.
- statt and anstatt are very close in meaning.
- statt is more common and sounds a bit simpler and more colloquial.
- anstatt can sound slightly more formal or literary, but it is not wrong or rare.
In everyday speech and writing, statt dass is usually preferred, but anstatt dass is fully acceptable here with no real change in meaning.