Breakdown of Hast du die Voraussetzung erfüllt, bevor du dich beworben hast?
du
you
haben
to have
bevor
before
dich
you
die Voraussetzung
the prerequisite
die
the; (feminine, nominative)
erfüllen
to fulfill
bewerben
to apply
Elon.io is an online learning platform
We have an entire course teaching German grammar and vocabulary.
Questions & Answers about Hast du die Voraussetzung erfüllt, bevor du dich beworben hast?
Why does the main clause start with Hast du instead of du hast?
In German yes-no questions the finite verb comes first (verb–subject). Here hast (the auxiliary for the perfect tense) is in position 1, du (the subject) in position 2. In a statement you’d say Du hast die Voraussetzung erfüllt, but to turn it into a question you invert subject and verb: Hast du … erfüllt?
Why is there a comma before bevor and why does bevor push the verb to the end of its clause?
Bevor is a subordinating conjunction (“before”). In German any clause introduced by a subordinating conjunction is set off by a comma, and the finite verb moves to the very end of that subordinate clause. So after bevor you get du (subject), dich (reflexive pronoun), beworben (past participle) and finally hast (auxiliary).
Why are there two instances of hast in the sentence?
Because both clauses are in the perfect tense (Perfekt). Each clause needs its own auxiliary verb haben (conjugated as hast for du). One hast belongs to the main clause (Hast du … erfüllt?), the other to the subordinate clause (bevor du dich … beworben hast).
Could I use the simple past (Präteritum) instead of the perfect (Perfekt) here?
You could, but native speakers—especially in speech—prefer Perfekt for past actions. Präteritum forms like Erfülltest du die Voraussetzung, bevor du dich beworben hast? sound overly formal or literary. In everyday conversation stick with Perfekt.
What’s the difference between bevor and nachdem, since both relate to “before/after”?
- Bevor = “before” (introduces an action that happens prior to the main clause action). Both clauses often use the same tense (here: Perfekt).
- Nachdem = “after” (the subordinate action happened before the main action, so German normally uses Plusquamperfekt in the subordinate clause and Perfekt in the main clause).
Example with nachdem:
Nachdem du dich beworben hattest (Plusquamperfekt), hast du die Voraussetzung erfüllt (Perfekt)?
What case is die Voraussetzung and why is it feminine?
Voraussetzung is a feminine noun (article die in nominative and accusative). Here it’s the direct object of erfüllen, so it remains die Voraussetzung (accusative).
Why do we need dich in du dich beworben hast?
Sich bewerben is a reflexive verb in German. The reflexive pronoun dich (accusative form for “du”) is mandatory to form “to apply” (for something). Without dich the verb wouldn’t be reflexive and the sentence would be ungrammatical.
Can I start with the subordinate clause and what changes then?
Yes. You can say:
Bevor du dich beworben hast, hast du die Voraussetzung erfüllt?
You still need the comma, and the main clause follows with its finite verb (hast) in second position.
How would I answer this question in a full sentence?
You can simply reply in perfect tense, mirroring the structure:
Ja, ich habe die Voraussetzung erfüllt, bevor ich mich beworben habe.
Or more briefly:
Ja, ich habe sie erfüllt.