Breakdown of Der Vogel vor dem Bahnhof singt laut, obwohl es viele Wolken am Himmel gibt.
dem
the; (masculine or neuter, dative)
es
it
singen
to sing
geben
to give
viele
many
der Himmel
the sky
vor
in front of
der Bahnhof
the train station
der Vogel
the bird
laut
loudly
obwohl
although
die Wolke
the cloud
Elon.io is an online learning platform
We have an entire course teaching German grammar and vocabulary.
Questions & Answers about Der Vogel vor dem Bahnhof singt laut, obwohl es viele Wolken am Himmel gibt.
What case is used in the phrase dem Bahnhof, and why is that case chosen?
The preposition vor expresses a static location (i.e., “in front of”) in this context, which requires the dative case. Therefore, dem Bahnhof is in the dative form to indicate where the bird is located.
Why is there a comma before obwohl in the sentence?
Obwohl is a subordinating conjunction that introduces a subordinate clause in German. According to German punctuation rules, such subordinate clauses must be separated from the main clause by a comma.
Why does the finite verb gibt appear at the end of the clause obwohl es viele Wolken am Himmel gibt?
In German subordinate clauses introduced by conjunctions like obwohl, the finite verb is placed at the end. This contrasts with the main clause word order where the verb typically occupies the second position, making the sentence structure clear.
What is the meaning of the expression es gibt, and how does it function in this sentence?
The phrase es gibt means “there is” or “there are” in English. It introduces the existence of something—in this case, many clouds. The construction emphasizes that clouds exist in the sky, with the phrase following the standard word order for this expression.
What does the contraction am in am Himmel stand for, and why is it used here?
Am is a contraction of an dem. It is used with the preposition an to indicate location in the dative case. In this sentence, am Himmel indicates the location “in the sky” where the many clouds are found.