Le plombier dit que ce tuyau n’est plus étanche.

Questions & Answers about Le plombier dit que ce tuyau n’est plus étanche.

Why does the sentence start with Le plombier instead of just plombier?

In French, singular countable nouns usually need a determiner, such as le, un, ce, etc.

So:

  • le plombier = the plumber
  • un plombier = a plumber

You normally cannot say just plombier as the subject of a sentence in standard French.

What does dit mean here, and what verb is it from?

Dit is the third-person singular present form of the verb dire, which means to say or to tell.

So:

  • je dis = I say
  • tu dis = you say
  • il/elle dit = he/she says

In this sentence, Le plombier dit... means The plumber says...

Why is que used in the middle of the sentence?

Que means that and introduces a subordinate clause.

So:

  • Le plombier dit = The plumber says
  • que ce tuyau n’est plus étanche = that this pipe is no longer watertight

Just like English often uses that, French uses que very commonly after verbs like:

  • dire = to say
  • penser = to think
  • croire = to believe
Why is it ce tuyau and not cet tuyau?

French uses:

Tuyau is masculine singular, but it starts with the consonant sound t, so you use ce:

  • ce tuyau = this pipe

You would use cet in something like:

  • cet homme = this man
  • cet appartement = this apartment
Why is there an apostrophe in n’est?

This is because ne becomes n’ before a vowel sound.

Here:

  • ne + est becomes n’est

This is called elision. French often drops the vowel in small words before another vowel sound:

  • je aime becomes j’aime
  • le ami becomes l’ami
  • ne est becomes n’est
What does ne ... plus mean?

Ne ... plus means no longer or not anymore.

In this sentence:

  • n’est plus étanche = is no longer watertight

It shows that something used to be true before, but is not true now.

Compare:

  • Il est étanche. = It is watertight.
  • Il n’est pas étanche. = It is not watertight.
  • Il n’est plus étanche. = It is no longer watertight.

That last one suggests a change of state.

What is the difference between ne ... pas and ne ... plus?

Both are negative structures, but they mean different things:

Examples:

  • Ce tuyau n’est pas étanche. = This pipe is not watertight.
  • Ce tuyau n’est plus étanche. = This pipe is no longer watertight.

So plus adds the idea that it used to be watertight before.

What does étanche mean exactly?

Étanche means something like:

  • watertight
  • airtight
  • sealed
  • leak-proof

The exact English translation depends on context.

With tuyau (pipe), étanche usually means that it does not leak.

So in this sentence, the plumber is saying the pipe is not sealed properly anymore or is leaking now.

Why is it étanche and not a different form? Does it agree with tuyau?

Yes, étanche is an adjective, and it agrees with the noun it describes.

Here, tuyau is:

The adjective form is:

  • étanche for masculine singular
  • étanche for feminine singular
  • étanches for plural

So the singular masculine form is correct in:

  • ce tuyau est étanche

If it were plural:

  • ces tuyaux sont étanches
Why is the verb est singular?

Because the subject of the second clause is ce tuyau, which is singular.

Breakdown:

  • ce tuyau = this pipe
  • est = is

So:

  • ce tuyau est... = this pipe is...

If the subject were plural, the verb would change:

  • ces tuyaux sont... = these pipes are...
How is plus pronounced here?

In ne ... plus, plus is usually pronounced plu when it means no longer / not anymore.

So:

  • n’est plus étanche is typically pronounced roughly like nay plu ay-tansh

Important: plus does not always sound the same in French. Its pronunciation changes depending on meaning and context.

For learners, the key point here is:

  • in ne ... plus, you will very often hear plu rather than plus
How is étanche pronounced?

Étanche is pronounced roughly like ay-tansh.

A few helpful points:

  • é sounds like ay
  • an is a nasal vowel, not a full an sound like in English
  • che sounds like sh

So the ending is not pronounced like English ch in chair. It is a sh sound.

Could French speakers leave out ne and just say est plus étanche?

In informal spoken French, many speakers drop ne in everyday conversation.

So you may hear:

  • Ce tuyau est plus étanche

But this can be ambiguous, because without ne, it may sound like:

  • This pipe is more watertight

For that reason, context and pronunciation matter a lot. In careful speech and in writing, ne is kept:

  • Ce tuyau n’est plus étanche

As a learner, it is safest to use the full written form.

Why is the sentence order so similar to English here?

Because this sentence follows a very common French pattern:

subject + verb + que + subject + verb + complement

So:

  • Le plombier = subject
  • dit = verb
  • que = that
  • ce tuyau = subject of the second clause
  • n’est plus étanche = verb phrase + adjective

French and English often line up quite closely with this type of sentence:

  • The plumber says that this pipe is no longer watertight.
  • Le plombier dit que ce tuyau n’est plus étanche.

That makes this a nice sentence for seeing how French clauses are built.

AI Language TutorTry it ↗
Your avatar
How does grammatical gender work in French?
Every French noun is either masculine or feminine, and this affects the articles and adjectives used with it. "Le" is used with masculine nouns and "la" with feminine ones. Adjectives also change form to match — for example, "petit" (masc.) becomes "petite" (fem.).

Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor

Start learning French

Master French — from Le plombier dit que ce tuyau n’est plus étanche to fluency

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
  • Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
  • Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
  • AI tutor to answer your grammar questions