Breakdown of Telefon ne radi niti prima poruke.
Questions & Answers about Telefon ne radi niti prima poruke.
Why is there only one ne in the sentence? Why not Telefon ne radi niti ne prima poruke?
Because niti already carries the negative idea of nor.
So:
- Telefon ne radi niti prima poruke. = The phone doesn’t work nor does it receive messages.
In standard Croatian, niti is commonly used after an already negative first clause, and the second verb usually does not need another ne.
A very common alternative is:
- Telefon ne radi i ne prima poruke.
This is often easier for learners, and it means the same thing: The phone doesn’t work and doesn’t receive messages.
What exactly does niti mean here?
Here niti means nor.
It connects two negative ideas:
- ne radi = doesn’t work
- niti prima poruke = nor does it receive messages
So the structure is basically:
- not X, nor Y
Croatian also has related forms:
- ni = often not even / nor / neither
- niti = a stronger or fuller conjunction, often matching nor
In this sentence, niti is a standard, natural connector.
What does radi mean here? I thought raditi means to work as in having a job.
Raditi can mean several things, depending on context.
Common meanings include:
- to work = to function
- to work = to have a job / do work
In this sentence, because the subject is telefon, radi clearly means:
- functions
- is working
So:
- Telefon radi. = The phone works / The phone is functioning.
- Telefon ne radi. = The phone doesn’t work / The phone isn’t functioning.
You would understand the job-related meaning only with a human subject, for example:
- On radi u Zagrebu. = He works in Zagreb.
Why is prima used? What verb is that?
Prima is the 3rd person singular present tense of primati, which means to receive.
So:
- primati = to receive
- prima = he/she/it receives
Since telefon is singular, the verb must also be singular:
- Telefon prima poruke. = The phone receives messages.
Croatian often uses present tense here just like English:
- The phone doesn’t receive messages.
Why is it poruke, not poruka?
Because poruke is the accusative plural, which is the form used for the direct object here.
The noun is:
- poruka = message (singular)
Plural nominative:
- poruke = messages
Plural accusative:
- poruke = messages
For this noun, the plural nominative and plural accusative happen to look the same.
So:
- prima poruke = receives messages
If it were singular, you would say:
- prima poruku = receives a message
Why is there no word for the in Telefon?
Because Croatian has no articles.
English uses:
- the phone
- a phone
Croatian usually just says:
- telefon
Context tells you whether it means the phone, a phone, or just phone/phones in a general sense.
So:
- Telefon ne radi. can mean The phone doesn’t work or, in some contexts, A phone doesn’t work.
In this sentence, the natural English translation is The phone doesn’t work...
Is the subject telefon in the nominative case?
Yes.
Telefon is the subject of both verbs:
- ne radi
- prima
Subjects are normally in the nominative case in Croatian.
So here:
- telefon = nominative singular
It is a masculine noun, and that matches the singular verb forms:
- radi
- prima
Could I also say Telefon ne radi i ne prima poruke?
Yes, absolutely.
That version is very common and often easier to understand for learners.
Compare:
- Telefon ne radi niti prima poruke.
- Telefon ne radi i ne prima poruke.
Both mean essentially the same thing:
- The phone doesn’t work and doesn’t receive messages.
The version with niti is a bit more compact and corresponds more closely to nor in English. The version with i ne is often more straightforward in everyday speech.
Why is the word order Telefon ne radi niti prima poruke? Could the words move around?
Croatian word order is more flexible than English, but this sentence uses the most neutral, natural order:
- subject + negation + verb + conjunction + verb + object
So:
- Telefon = subject
- ne radi = first negative clause
- niti prima poruke = second coordinated clause
You can sometimes move words for emphasis, but the basic version is best for learners.
For example, this is the standard neutral form:
- Telefon ne radi niti prima poruke.
Changing the order might sound marked, poetic, or context-dependent.
Is this describing something happening right now, or a general fact?
It can be either, depending on context.
The present tense in Croatian can describe:
- a current situation
- a general property
- a repeated/habitual action
So this sentence could mean:
- The phone isn’t working and isn’t receiving messages right now.
- or This phone doesn’t work and doesn’t receive messages (in general / as a problem).
In real life, context tells you which is meant.
Why is primati used instead of a perfective verb?
Because the sentence describes an ongoing state or ability, not a single completed event.
Primati is imperfective, and that fits meanings like:
- receive
- be receiving
- be able to receive
- receive regularly
Here the idea is not:
- The phone failed to receive one specific message
but rather:
- The phone is not receiving messages at all / in general
So the imperfective present prima is the natural choice.
If you wanted a one-time completed event, Croatian would use a different structure, for example with a perfective verb and usually a past tense.
Does poruke specifically mean text messages?
Often, yes, in modern everyday usage.
Poruka means message, and in many contexts:
- poruke = messages
- very often understood as text messages
But the exact meaning depends on context. It could also mean messages more generally, including app messages or notifications, depending on the situation.
If someone is talking about a phone problem, English speakers will often naturally interpret:
- ne prima poruke as isn’t receiving messages/texts
Can Telefon ne radi also mean The phone is broken?
Yes, very often that is the practical meaning.
Literally, it means:
- The phone doesn’t work
- The phone isn’t functioning
Depending on context, that may imply:
- the phone is broken
- the phone has no signal
- the phone is malfunctioning
- the phone is off or unusable
So ne radi is slightly broader than just is broken. It focuses on the fact that it is not functioning, whatever the exact reason may be.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning CroatianMaster Croatian — from Telefon ne radi niti prima poruke to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions