Breakdown of Seitdem ich im Retreat bin, brauche ich kein Smartphone.
ich
I
sein
to be
kein
no, not any
brauchen
to need
im
in the (used with months) / in the (contraction of in + dem)
seitdem
since
das Retreat
the retreat
das Smartphone
the smartphone
Questions & Answers about Seitdem ich im Retreat bin, brauche ich kein Smartphone.
Why does the German sentence use the present tense (bin) when the English translation says "have been"?
In German, when an action started in the past and is still ongoing in the present, you use the present tense. Because the person is still at the retreat right now, German uses bin. English, on the other hand, requires the present perfect ("have been") for this situation.
Why does the main clause start with the verb brauche right after the comma?
This is due to the strict "verb second" rule in German. The entire subordinate clause (Seitdem ich im Retreat bin) takes up the first position in the sentence. To keep the main verb in the second position, brauche must come immediately after the comma, followed by the subject ich.
What is the difference between seitdem and seit?
Seitdem is a conjunction used to connect two full clauses, which is why it introduces a phrase with a subject and a verb at the end (ich... bin). Seit is a preposition used directly before a time expression or a noun (for example, seit gestern - since yesterday). Note that in casual speech, native speakers sometimes use seit as a conjunction too, but seitdem is the grammatically correct choice here.
Why use kein Smartphone instead of nicht ein Smartphone?
In German, when you negate a noun that would normally take an indefinite article (like "a smartphone"), you must use kein (not a / no). Using nicht ein sounds unnatural to a German speaker unless you are strongly emphasizing the number one (as in, "not one smartphone, but two").
Learn Seitdem ich im Retreat bin, brauche ich kein Smartphone and more in German
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
- ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
- ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free