Breakdown of Während der Stoßzeit sind die Züge zwar überfüllt, aber pünktlich.
sein
to be
aber
but
der Zug
the train
pünktlich
on time / punctual
während
during
zwar
admittedly
die Stoßzeit
the rush hour
überfüllt
overcrowded
Questions & Answers about Während der Stoßzeit sind die Züge zwar überfüllt, aber pünktlich.
How does the structure zwar ... aber work in this specific sentence?
The two-part conjunction zwar ... aber means "admittedly ... but" or "it is true that ... but". Here, it connects two contrasting adjectives: überfüllt (overcrowded) and pünktlich (punctual). It perfectly highlights the trade-off: you accept the negative point because of the positive one.
Why isn't there a second verb or subject after aber?
The word aber is a coordinating conjunction, which means it can connect two parallel things. Because both überfüllt and pünktlich describe the exact same subject (die Züge) using the exact same verb (sind), you don't need to repeat the subject and verb. You could technically say aber sie sind pünktlich, but leaving the extra words out sounds much more natural.
Could I put zwar at the very beginning of the sentence instead?
Yes, but it forces a change in word order. If you start with Zwar, it takes the first position, meaning the verb must immediately follow it: Zwar sind die Züge während der Stoßzeit überfüllt, aber pünktlich. In our original sentence, the time phrase Während der Stoßzeit takes position one, so the verb comes second, and zwar sits later in the clause.
Why is it der Stoßzeit if the noun is feminine (die Stoßzeit)?
The preposition während (during) requires the genitive case. In the genitive case, the feminine article die changes to der. This is a great reminder that not every der you see in a sentence means a noun is masculine!
Learn Während der Stoßzeit sind die Züge zwar überfüllt, aber pünktlich and more in German
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
- ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
- ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free