Question 1

Why does this sentence use non pas instead of making the verb negative with ne... pas?

Accepted Answer

Using non pas directly contrasts two elements—here, the slaves and the workers. If you said Ce ne sont pas des esclaves, you would simply be negating the verb. non pas creates an emphatic correction meaning 'not this, but that'.

Question 2

Can I drop the non and just say Ce sont pas des esclaves?

Accepted Answer

In casual spoken French, people often drop ne from ne... pas, but here non pas is a fixed phrase used for contrasting. You cannot drop non because pas on its own only negates a verb. To negate a specific noun phrase for a contrast, you must use non pas.

Question 3

Why is it Ce sont instead of C'est at the beginning?

Accepted Answer

When highlighting a noun using the c'est... qui (it is... who) structure, the verb must match the noun that follows. Because des esclaves is plural, you must use the plural ce sont. You will sometimes hear native speakers use c'est before a plural in informal speech, but ce sont is grammatically correct here.

Question 4

What is the purpose of the Ce sont... qui... structure?

Accepted Answer

This structure is used to put strong emphasis on the subject. Instead of simply saying Des ouvriers ont construit la pyramide (Workers built the pyramid), wrapping it in Ce sont... qui puts the spotlight entirely on the identity of the builders, which perfectly supports the emphatic non pas... mais... contrast.

Ce sont non pas des esclaves, mais des ouvriers qui ont construit la pyramide.

Breakdown of Ce sont non pas des esclaves, mais des ouvriers qui ont construit la pyramide.

Questions & Answers about Ce sont non pas des esclaves, mais des ouvriers qui ont construit la pyramide.

Learn Ce sont non pas des esclaves, mais des ouvriers qui ont construit la pyramide and more in French