Breakdown of S jedne strane želim putovati, a s druge strane nemam novca.
a
and / but
željeti
to want
nemati
to not have
novac
money
putovati
to travel
s druge strane
on the other hand
s jedne strane
on the one hand
Questions & Answers about S jedne strane želim putovati, a s druge strane nemam novca.
Why is the preposition s used with the genitive case in s jedne strane? Doesn't s usually take the instrumental?
You are right that s (or sa) usually means "with" and takes the instrumental case. However, s can also mean "from" or "off of" when paired with the genitive case. In Croatian, you look at things "from" a side, so s jedne strane literally means "from one side".
Could I use i instead of a to connect these two clauses since the English translation says "and"?
No, a is exactly the right conjunction here. Even though English uses "and", you are contrasting two opposing situations (wanting to travel vs. having no money). In Croatian, a is the perfect contrastive conjunction for this, whereas i simply adds similar information together and ali (but) would feel a bit too strong.
Why is it nemam novca (genitive) instead of nemam novac (accusative)?
While you will hear people use the accusative (novac) in everyday speech, using the genitive (novca) is grammatically preferred when dealing with an unspecified quantity (the partitive genitive) or after a negative verb. It implies "I don't have (any) money."
Is it necessary to repeat the word strane in the second half of the sentence?
It is very common to repeat it, but not strictly necessary. Just like in English where you can say "on the other", in Croatian you could drop the second strane and just say a s druge nemam novca. However, keeping the full phrase s druge strane sounds very natural and balanced.
Learn S jedne strane želim putovati, a s druge strane nemam novca and more in Croatian
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
- ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
- ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free