Breakdown of Du borde ha börjat buda när antikviteten kom fram.
du
you (singular)
ha
to have
börja
to start
när
when
böra
should, ought to
komma fram
to arrive, to get there
buda
to bid
antikviteten
the antique
Questions & Answers about Du borde ha börjat buda när antikviteten kom fram.
Why do we use the supine form börjat here instead of the past tense började?
This sentence expresses an unfulfilled past obligation. After the helper phrase borde ha (should have), you must use the supine form börjat. This works just like English, where you use a past participle after the auxiliary verb have.
Is it possible to drop the word ha in this sentence?
Yes! In spoken and informal written Swedish, it is extremely common to drop ha between past-tense modal verbs like borde, kunde, or skulle and the supine verb. Saying Du borde börjat is perfectly correct and sounds very natural.
Why is there no att before buda? Doesn't the sentence mean 'started to bid'?
While you can grammatically say börjat att buda, Swedish almost always drops the infinitive marker att after verbs that indicate the start, stop, or continuation of an action, such as börja and sluta. The infinitive buda simply attaches directly to the previous verb.
I know the verb bjuda means to invite or offer. Is buda related?
Yes, buda is derived from bjuda, but it has taken on a very specific, practical meaning. You use buda specifically when talking about placing bids in an auction or bidding on a house.
The phrasal verb kom fram usually means 'arrived', doesn't it?
It frequently means to arrive or reach a destination, but in this specific context, komma fram means to emerge, appear, or be brought out into the open. It describes the moment the antique was physically presented to the bidders.
Learn Du borde ha börjat buda när antikviteten kom fram and more in Swedish
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
- ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
- ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free