Usted dijo que el ladrón cometía el crimen y amenazaba al guardia.

Questions & Answers about Usted dijo que el ladrón cometía el crimen y amenazaba al guardia.

Why are the verbs cometía and amenazaba in the imperfect tense here?
This is a classic example of reported speech. Because the reporting verb is in the past (dijo), the tense of the original statement shifts a step back in time. The original speaker used the present tense to describe what was happening. When reporting those present-tense actions in the past, they shift to the imperfect tense.
What would the original direct quote look like in Spanish?
The direct quote would be: El ladrón comete el crimen y amenaza al guardia. When you report this with Usted dijo que..., those present tense verbs (comete, amenaza) change to their imperfect forms (cometía, amenazaba).
The English translation says "was committing" and "threatening". Could I just translate it as "committed" and "threatened"?
You could, but translating them as "was committing" and "[was] threatening" better captures the ongoing, descriptive nature of the imperfect tense. It highlights that the crime and threats were actively in progress at the time you were talking about.
Why is there an al before guardia?
This is the "personal a" combined with the masculine article el (a + el = al). Whenever a specific person (like the guard) is the direct object receiving the action of a verb—in this case, being threatened—Spanish requires you to put an a in front of them.

Learn Usted dijo que el ladrón cometía el crimen y amenazaba al guardia and more in Spanish

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • Practice with interactive exercises
  • Track your progress with spaced repetition
  • Learn at your own pace — completely free