Log inSign up

¿Hay un menú en la mesa?

¿Hay un menú en la mesa?
Is there a menu on the table?
From Lesson 39:Stem-changing verbs (e to i)·Spanish (Latin America)

Questions & Answers about ¿Hay un menú en la mesa?

Wait, doesn't hay mean "there is"? Why does it mean "is there" in this sentence?
In Spanish, you don't need to swap words around to turn a statement into a question like we do in English with "there is" and "is there". Hay un menú means "There is a menu." By just adding question marks and raising the pitch of your voice at the end, ¿Hay un menú? becomes "Is there a menu?"
I learned that en means "in". Why is it translated as "on the table" here?
The Spanish preposition en is very versatile. It covers "in," "on," and "at" depending on the context. Since menus don't usually go inside tables, en la mesa naturally means "on the table" here.
Why is there an accent mark on the word menú?
In Spanish, words that end in a vowel naturally stress the second-to-last syllable. If it didn't have an accent mark, you would pronounce it ME-nu. The accent mark shows that this word breaks the rules and the stress goes on the final syllable instead (me-NU).
Why do we use hay here instead of está?
We use hay (is there / there is) when we want to know if something merely exists, which is why it is paired here with the general article un (a). If we were asking about the location of a specific menu, we would use a form of estar, as in ¿Dónde está el menú? (Where is the menu?).

Learn ¿Hay un menú en la mesa and more in Spanish

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
  • ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
  • ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free
Start learning Spanish →