Breakdown of Скульптор, с которым ты разговаривал, любит глину.
ты
you (singular)
любить
to love, to like
разговаривать
to talk
с
with (also со)
который
which / who / that (relative pronoun)
скульптор
the sculptor
глина
the clay
Questions & Answers about Скульптор, с которым ты разговаривал, любит глину.
Why do we use которым here instead of который or которого?
The word который (who/which) always matches the noun it refers to (скульптор) in gender and number, which is why it is masculine singular here. However, its case is determined by its role inside the relative clause. Because you were talking with him, it requires the preposition с followed by the Instrumental case, making it с которым.
Could I use говорил instead of разговаривал?
Yes, you could absolutely say с которым ты говорил. Both work, but разговаривать specifically emphasizes an active, two-way conversation or chat, which pairs very naturally with с (with). Говорить is a slightly broader verb for speaking or talking.
Are the commas around с которым ты разговаривал optional?
No, they are strictly required. In English, we sometimes skip commas if the description is essential to knowing who we mean (like 'The sculptor you spoke with...'). In Russian, any relative clause starting with a form of который must always be separated from the rest of the sentence by commas.
Why is the main thought (Скульптор любит глину) split in half?
In Russian, a relative clause should ideally be placed immediately after the noun it describes so it's clear who you are talking about. Since it describes the subject (скульптор), it gets inserted right after it, pausing the main idea until the description is finished, after which the main verb (любит) appears.
Learn Скульптор, с которым ты разговаривал, любит глину and more in Russian
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
- ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
- ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free