Breakdown of Estas garrafas são de vidro ou de plástico?
ser
to be
este
this
de
of, from / in (with times of day)
ou
or
a garrafa
the bottle
o plástico
the plastic
o vidro
the glass (material)
Questions & Answers about Estas garrafas são de vidro ou de plástico?
Why do we need de before vidro and plástico?
In English, a material like glass or plastic can be used directly after the verb ("Are these bottles glass?"). In Portuguese, you use de + the material, which literally means "of glass" or "made of glass": de vidro, de plástico. It is also most natural to repeat de after ou (de vidro ou de plástico) so it is clear that both words refer to the material.
Why don't vidro and plástico change to feminine plural to match garrafas?
Because vidro (glass) and plástico (plastic) are nouns here, not adjectives. When you use de + a noun to say what something is made of, the material noun keeps its own gender and stays singular, whether you are talking about um copo de vidro (a glass cup) or estas garrafas de vidro (these glass bottles).
Why is são used here instead of estão?
Can I say essas garrafas instead of estas garrafas?
Yes! In formal grammar, estas means "these" (near the speaker) and essas means "those" (near the listener). However, in everyday Brazilian Portuguese, speakers very commonly use essas for both "these" and "those." Both Estas garrafas and Essas garrafas work well here.
Why doesn't são go at the beginning of the sentence to make a question?
Unlike English, which flips the word order ("These bottles are..." → "Are these bottles...?"), Portuguese yes/no questions normally keep the exact same word order as statements. In writing, the question mark shows it is a question, and in speech, you simply raise the pitch of your voice at the end.
Learn Estas garrafas são de vidro ou de plástico and more in Portuguese
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
- ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
- ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free