Willingness and conditions (se depender de, ser questão de, se for o caso)

At a neighborhood repair café, volunteers do o reparo (the repair) on broken appliances like a cafeteira (the coffee maker), a batedeira (the mixer), and a torradeira (the toaster). While diagnosing and fixing them, three patterns come up all the time. They express personal willingness, narrow a problem down, and set conditions for next steps: no que depender de / se depender de, ser questão de, and se for o caso (de).

Personal willingness: no que depender de and se depender de

Both no que depender de (as far as it depends on) and se depender de (if it is up to) express someone's readiness or commitment to make something happen. Here depender is the future subjunctive of depender (to depend), which looks identical to the infinitive.

Pay attention to what follows de:

  • With pronouns, use mim for the first person singular (de mim, on me), alongside de você (on you) and de nós (on us).
  • With nouns and people's names (names commonly take a definite article in Brazilian speech), de contracts with the article: do Lucas (de + o), da Helena and da nossa equipe (de + a).

In the main clause, everyday Brazilian Portuguese typically uses the present indicative with future meaning (o reparo sai hoje, volta a funcionar já). The future tense (será) also appears, in slightly more formal statements. At the end of a clause like this, já means right away.

As far as it depends on me, the coffee maker repair will be done today.
No que depender de mim, o reparo da cafeteira sai hoje.
As far as it depends on our team, every repair will be free.
No que depender da nossa equipe, todo reparo será gratuito.
If it is up to Helena, this mixer will work again right away.
Se depender da Helena, esta batedeira volta a funcionar já.
If it is up to us, nobody throws away the coffee maker or the mixer.
Se depender de nós, ninguém joga fora a cafeteira nem a batedeira.
Although the defect is serious, as far as it depends on Lucas, it can be fixed.
Embora o defeito seja grave, no que depender do Lucas, tem conserto.

Narrowing an issue down: ser questão de

Once you open an appliance to inspect o fio (the wire, the cord) or decide whether to soldar (solder) a loose contact, you often want to boil the problem down to a single step or requirement. For this, use ser questão de (to be a matter of).

You will hear it both without an article (é questão de...) and with uma, especially after só (just): é só uma questão de... (it is just a matter of...). Two structures can follow de:

  • de + infinitive names the required action: é só uma questão de trocar o fio (it is just a matter of replacing the cord).
  • de + noun or time phrase names what is needed: é questão de cinco minutos (it is a matter of five minutes), é só uma questão de paciência (it is just a matter of patience).
Is the problem with the toaster just a matter of replacing the cord?
O problema da torradeira é só uma questão de trocar o fio?
We just need to open the base; after that, it is a matter of soldering the wire.
Falta apenas abrir a base; depois, é questão de soldar o fio.
Who can solder the toaster wire? It is a matter of five minutes!
Quem pode soldar o fio da torradeira? É questão de cinco minutos!
Finding the loose wire on the panel is just a matter of patience.
Encontrar o fio solto no painel é só uma questão de paciência.

Conditional next steps: se for o caso (de)

When repairing something, you often try a simple fix first and keep a backup plan in reserve. To make an action depend on whether the situation actually calls for it, use se for o caso (if need be, if that is the case). Here for is the future subjunctive of ser.

It works in two patterns:

  • Alone (se for o caso): refers back to the situation already mentioned and means if need be or if necessary.
  • With de + infinitive (se for o caso de...): spells out the specific step (if it comes to doing X).

As with se depender de, the result clause usually takes the present indicative in spoken Brazilian Portuguese. Examples are ajusto (I will adjust), usamos (we will use), and a gente desmonta (we will take it apart).

I am going to test the mixer motor and, if need be, I will adjust the gear.
Vou testar o motor da batedeira e, se for o caso, ajusto a engrenagem.
If it comes to taking the whole coffee maker apart, we will take it apart.
Se for o caso de desmontar a cafeteira inteira, a gente desmonta.
There is no point in forcing the lid; if need be, we will use another tool.
Não adianta forçar a tampa; se for o caso, usamos outra ferramenta.

Summary

ExpressionWhat it expressesWhat followsExample
no que depender de / se depender dePersonal willingness or commitment (as far as it depends on / if it is up to)Pronoun (mim, nós) or noun/name (do Lucas, da equipe)No que depender de mim, sai hoje. (As far as it depends on me, it will be done today.)
ser (só uma) questão deNarrowing an issue down (to be [just] a matter of)Infinitive (soldar) or noun/time phrase (paciência, cinco minutos)É questão de soldar o fio. (It is a matter of soldering the wire.)
se for o caso (de)Conditional action (if need be / if it comes to)Nothing, or de + infinitive (de desmontar)Se for o caso, usamos outra ferramenta. (If need be, we will use another tool.)

Contributors