Acting like vs. acting as if (como quem, como se)

Around a card table, half the game is how you carry yourself. As players embaralhar (shuffle) o baralho (the deck of cards), push as fichas (the chips) into the center, and descartar (discard) cards, everyone is reading everyone else's attitude. To describe how someone is acting, Brazilian Portuguese contrasts two expressions: como quem (like someone who…) and como se (as if…).

Now it is time to shuffle the deck of cards for the next round.
Agora é hora de embaralhar o baralho para a próxima rodada.

Outward demeanor: como quem + present indicative

Como quem (like someone who) describes a person's visible demeanor, body language, or attitude by comparing them to a typical person in that state.

Quem is grammatically 3rd-person singular, so the verb after como quem is 3rd-person singular. It is usually in the present indicative (tem, sabe, esconde, quer), even when the main sentence is in the past or has a different subject like eu or você:

  • Ele falou como quem sabe do assunto. (He spoke like someone who knows the subject.)
  • Você sorriu como quem não tem pressa. (You smiled like someone who is in no hurry.)

A past-tense verb after como quem (como quem sabia) also occurs, but the present is the typical pattern.

Ana shuffled the deck of cards slowly, like someone who is in no hurry.
Ana embaralhou o baralho devagar, como quem não tem pressa.
Júlia put the chips on the table, confident, like someone who already knows the result.
Júlia pôs as fichas na mesa, confiante, como quem já sabe o resultado.
Lucas discarded three cards and limited himself to smiling, like someone who is hiding a secret.
Lucas descartou três cartas e se limitou a sorrir, como quem esconde um segredo.
Why did you hesitate in the tensest round, like someone who is afraid to take a risk?
Por que você hesitou na rodada mais tensa, como quem tem medo de arriscar?

Acting as if: como se + imperfect subjunctive

When players blefar (bluff), you often want to say someone is acting as if something were true when it isn't, or might not be. For these hypothetical or counterfactual comparisons, Portuguese uses como se (as if / as though) followed by the imperfect subjunctive (the -sse form).

Unlike como quem, the verb after como se agrees with its own subject. It stays in the imperfect subjunctive whether the main clause is in the present or the past. For something that would have happened earlier, use tivesse + past participle (como se tivesse visto, as if he had seen).

InfinitiveImperfect subjunctive (eu / você / ele / ela / a gente)With como se
ter (to have)tivessecomo se tivesse (as if he/she had)
valer (to be worth)valessecomo se não valesse (as if it were not worth)
ser (to be)fossecomo se não fosse (as if it were not)
saber (to know)soubessecomo se já soubesse (as if he/she already knew)
querer (to want)quisessecomo se não quisesse (as if he/she did not want)
Pedro is bluffing, but he pushes the chips as if he had the best hand.
Pedro está blefando, mas empurra as fichas como se tivesse a melhor mão.
Even while bluffing, Clara discarded the last card as if it were worth nothing.
Mesmo blefando, Clara descartou a última carta como se não valesse nada.
The atmosphere got tense, but Sofia remained calm, as if it were not a bluff.
O clima ficou tenso, mas Sofia permaneceu calma, como se não fosse um blefe.
How does he manage to seem so confident, as if he already knew our game?
Como ele consegue parecer tão confiante, como se já soubesse o nosso jogo?

Side by side: como quem vs. como se

Think of the difference as camera angle vs. reality check:

  • como quem
    • present indicative paints the outward pose (with the air of someone who…). A classic Brazilian idiom is como quem não quer nada (casually, nonchalantly; literally like someone who wants nothing).
  • como se
    • imperfect subjunctive frames a hypothetical scenario (as if it were true that…), often hinting that it isn't.

Compare:

  • Ela saiu devagar, como quem não quer nada. (She left slowly, like someone who wants nothing. This describes her casual demeanor.)
  • Ela saiu devagar, como se não quisesse nada. (She left slowly, as if she wanted nothing. This suggests she may only be pretending not to care.)

Because they highlight different angles of the same behavior, the two can be combined in one sentence:

She bet slowly, like someone who wants nothing, as if victory did not matter.
Ela apostou devagar, como quem não quer nada, como se a vitória não importasse.
Tiago looked at me like someone who accepts the challenge, as if he did not suspect the bluff.
Tiago olhou para mim como quem aceita o desafio, como se não desconfiasse do blefe.

Summary

ExpressionWhat it expressesVerb form that followsExample
como quemOutward demeanor (like someone who…)Usually present indicative, 3rd-person singularFalou como quem sabe. (Spoke like someone who knows.)
como seHypothetical or counterfactual act (as if…)Imperfect subjunctive (-sse), agreeing with its subjectFalou como se soubesse. (Spoke as if he/she knew.)