Breakdown of Rozmawiam z nim jako przewodniczącym.
on
he / it (m)
rozmawiać
to talk
z
with
jako
as (in the role of)
przewodniczący
chairman
Questions & Answers about Rozmawiam z nim jako przewodniczącym.
Why is przewodniczącym in the instrumental case here?
The particle jako (as) is 'transparent' for cases. It forces the noun after it to match the case of the noun or pronoun it describes. Since jako connects the chairman to nim (him), and nim is in the instrumental case after the preposition z (with), przewodniczącym must also take the instrumental case.
How would the sentence change if I were the chairman instead of him?
You would say: Rozmawiam z nim jako przewodniczący. Here, jako connects the chairman to the hidden subject ja (I). Since the subject is always in the nominative case, przewodniczący must also be in the nominative. The case you choose after jako tells the listener exactly who holds the role!
Why does przewodniczącym have the adjective ending -ym instead of a noun ending like -em?
Przewodniczący is an active adjectival participle—a verb form that describes what someone is doing (literally 'the presiding one'). Even though it acts as a noun in this sentence, it still declines exactly like a standard adjective. This is why its instrumental form takes the adjective ending -ym.
Why do we use nim for 'him' rather than niego?
The preposition z (when meaning 'with') requires the instrumental case. The instrumental form of the pronoun on (he) is nim. You would use niego for the genitive or accusative cases after a preposition (like dla niego or na niego).
Learn Rozmawiam z nim jako przewodniczącym and more in Polish
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
- ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
- ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free