Breakdown of Hon kan inte bestämma sig för vilken bok hon vill låna.
Questions & Answers about Hon kan inte bestämma sig för vilken bok hon vill låna.
Why does bestämma sig include sig?
Because bestämma sig is the usual Swedish expression for to decide / to make up one’s mind.
- bestämma by itself often means decide, determine, or set
- bestämma sig means decide oneself, idiomatically make up one’s mind
So in this sentence:
- Hon kan inte bestämma sig = She can’t make up her mind
The word sig is a reflexive pronoun, like oneself / herself.
Since the subject is hon, the reflexive form is still sig.
Compare:
- Jag bestämmer mig = I decide / make up my mind
- Du bestämmer dig = You decide
- Hon bestämmer sig = She decides
So this is a fixed and very common pattern in Swedish.
Why is there a för in bestämma sig för?
Because bestämma sig för is the full expression meaning decide on or choose something.
So:
- bestämma sig = make up one’s mind
- bestämma sig för något = decide on something
In your sentence:
- bestämma sig för vilken bok = decide on which book
This works much like English decide on in some contexts.
Examples:
- Jag måste bestämma mig för en färg. = I have to decide on a color.
- Han har bestämt sig för att resa. = He has decided to travel.
So the för belongs naturally with the verb phrase.
Why is it vilken bok and not vad bok?
Because vilken means which, and it is used when choosing among known or possible options.
- vilken bok = which book
- vad usually means what
Since the sentence is about choosing one book from some set of books, Swedish uses vilken, not vad.
Also, vilken changes form depending on the noun:
- vilken for common-gender singular nouns
- vilket for neuter singular nouns
- vilka for plural nouns
Here, bok is a common-gender singular noun, so:
- vilken bok = correct
Examples:
- vilken film = which film
- vilket hus = which house
- vilka böcker = which books
Why is hon repeated in vilken bok hon vill låna?
Because hon vill låna is a full subordinate clause, and Swedish normally needs the subject to be stated.
The structure is:
- Hon kan inte bestämma sig för
- vilken bok hon vill låna
That last part literally contains:
- which book she wants to borrow
Just like in English, you need she there.
You cannot normally leave it out and say:
- vilken bok vill låna ❌
That would be missing the subject.
So the second hon is not unnecessary repetition; it is simply the subject of the clause hon vill låna.
Why is there no att before låna?
Because vill is a modal verb, and modal verbs in Swedish are followed by the infinitive without att.
So:
- hon vill låna = she wants to borrow
This is similar to English:
- she wants to borrow
not she wants to to borrow
Common Swedish modal verbs include:
- kan = can
- vill = want to
- ska = will / shall / going to
- måste = must
- får = may / be allowed to
Examples:
- Jag kan simma. = I can swim.
- Hon vill läsa. = She wants to read.
- Vi måste gå. = We must go.
With many other verbs, Swedish does use att before the infinitive, but not after modal verbs.
Why is it kan inte and not inte kan?
Because Swedish main clauses usually follow V2 word order, meaning the finite verb comes in the second position.
In this sentence, the main clause begins with:
- Hon = subject
- kan = finite verb
- inte = negation
So the order is:
- Hon kan inte ...
That is the normal Swedish order in a main clause.
Compare:
If this were a subordinate clause, the word order could be different, with inte before the finite verb:
- ... att hon inte kan bestämma sig = ... that she cannot make up her mind
So this sentence is a good example of normal main-clause order.
Is låna always borrow, or can it also mean lend?
This is a very common source of confusion.
By itself, låna usually means borrow:
- Hon vill låna en bok. = She wants to borrow a book.
To say lend, Swedish often uses:
- låna ut = lend out / lend
Examples:
- Kan jag låna din penna? = Can I borrow your pen?
- Kan du låna ut din penna? = Can you lend me your pen?
So in your sentence, låna clearly means borrow.
What is the difference between bestämma and bestämma sig?
They are related, but not the same.
bestämma without sig can mean things like:
- decide
- determine
- set
- control
Examples:
- Chefen bestämmer. = The boss decides / is in charge.
- Vi måste bestämma tiden. = We must decide the time.
bestämma sig is more specifically to make up one’s mind.
Example:
- Jag kan inte bestämma mig. = I can’t make up my mind.
So in your sentence, bestämma sig is used because the idea is that she is struggling to choose.
How is the sentence structured overall?
It breaks down like this:
- Hon = she
- kan inte = cannot
- bestämma sig för = decide on / make up her mind about
- vilken bok = which book
- hon vill låna = she wants to borrow
So the structure is:
- She cannot decide on which book she wants to borrow
You can think of it in two parts:
- Main clause: Hon kan inte bestämma sig för ...
- Embedded question / subordinate clause: vilken bok hon vill låna
That second part is not a direct question, so Swedish does not use question word order there.
Compare:
Vilken bok vill hon låna? = Which book does she want to borrow?
direct questionJag vet vilken bok hon vill låna. = I know which book she wants to borrow.
embedded clause
Your sentence uses the second type.
Could Swedish also say this in a slightly different way?
Yes. A natural alternative is:
- Hon kan inte bestämma vilken bok hon vill låna.
This is also correct and natural.
The version with bestämma sig för feels a bit more like:
- She can’t make up her mind about which book to choose
The version without sig för is often a little more direct:
- She can’t decide which book she wants to borrow
Both are good Swedish, but bestämma sig för is especially useful because it highlights the idea of choosing among options.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning SwedishMaster Swedish — from Hon kan inte bestämma sig för vilken bok hon vill låna to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions