Questions & Answers about La criatura apareció ayer.
Because ayer means yesterday, which usually points to a completed event at a specific time in the past. In Spanish, that normally calls for the preterite:
- apareció = it/they/he/she appeared, showed up
- aparecía = it/they/he/she was appearing / used to appear / would appear
So:
- La criatura apareció ayer = a finished event yesterday
- La criatura aparecía cada noche = it used to appear every night