Guardamos el recurso de reposición por si lo desestiman.

Questions & Answers about Guardamos el recurso de reposición por si lo desestiman.

What does guardar mean here?

Here guardar most naturally means to keep, to hold onto, or to save for later use.

So Guardamos el recurso de reposición suggests something like:

  • We’re keeping the appeal
  • We’re holding the appeal in reserve
  • We’re saving it for later

It does not mean guard in the English sense, and it is probably not the computer meaning of save unless the context is explicitly digital.


Is guardamos present tense or past tense?

It can be either, because for -ar verbs, the nosotros form is the same in:

You tell the difference from context.

In this sentence, present is the more natural reading, because por si lo desestiman points to a possible future event:

  • We’re keeping the appeal in case they reject it

If it were clearly past, you would usually expect more past context, such as:

  • Guardamos el recurso de reposición por si lo desestimaban

What exactly is un recurso de reposición?

This is a fixed legal term in Spain.

A recurso de reposición is a type of administrative appeal in which you ask the same authority that made the decision to reconsider it.

A couple of useful points:

So it is better to think of recurso de reposición as one complete technical term, not to translate each word separately.


Why does the sentence use por si?

Por si means in case or just in case.

It expresses a precaution: you do something now because something else might happen later.

So:

  • Guardamos el recurso de reposición por si lo desestiman
  • We keep the appeal in case they reject it

This is different from plain si, which just means if.

Compare:

  • Si lo desestiman, actuaremos = If they reject it, we’ll act
  • Lo guardamos por si lo desestiman = We keep it in case they reject it

The second one focuses on preparation/precaution.


Why is it desestiman and not desestimen?

Because por si is normally followed by the indicative, not the subjunctive.

Spanish treats por si as referring to a possible real situation that you are preparing for:

  • por si viene = in case he/she comes
  • por si llueve = in case it rains
  • por si lo desestiman = in case they reject it

So desestiman is the expected form here.

Using desestimen after por si would sound non-standard in this structure.


What does lo refer to, and why is it lo?

Lo is a masculine singular direct object pronoun.

In isolation, the most natural thing it refers to is el recurso de reposición.

Why lo?

  • recurso is masculine singular
  • desestimar takes a direct object
  • so the standard pronoun is lo

That is why you get:

  • desestiman el recurso → lo desestiman

Not le, because le is normally for an indirect object (and in standard Spanish, not for things like this).

One small nuance: in a wider context, lo could refer to some other masculine singular noun already mentioned, but if you only look at this sentence, el recurso is the obvious reference.


Who are they in desestiman?

The subject is not stated, which is very normal in Spanish.

The ending -an already tells you it is third person plural:

  • desestiman = they reject / dismiss

In this legal context, they would usually mean something like:

  • the administration
  • the authority
  • the court
  • the decision-making body

Spanish often leaves subjects out when they are clear enough from the verb form or the context.


Is desestimar a common everyday verb?

It is mostly formal, especially legal or administrative.

In Spain, desestimar un recurso is a very standard legal expression meaning:

  • to dismiss an appeal
  • to reject an appeal

In everyday speech, people might more often use verbs like:

  • rechazar
  • denegar
  • no aceptar

So this sentence has a noticeably formal/legal register.


Why is it el recurso de reposición and not un recurso de reposición?

Because el points to a specific appeal, one that the speakers already have in mind.

So:

  • el recurso de reposición = the appeal / that specific appeal
  • un recurso de reposición = an appeal / some appeal

In legal or administrative contexts, the definite article is especially common when everyone involved knows which document or procedure is being discussed.

AI Language TutorTry it ↗
Your avatar
“What's the best way to learn Spanish grammar?”
Spanish grammar becomes intuitive with practice. Focus on understanding the core patterns first — how sentences are structured, how verbs change form, and how words relate to each other. Our course breaks these concepts into small lessons so you can build understanding step by step.

Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor

Start learning Spanish

Master Spanish — from Guardamos el recurso de reposición por si lo desestiman to fluency

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
  • ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
  • ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
  • ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions