Questions & Answers about Я взял не тот ключ и не смог открыть дверь.
взял is the perfective past form of взять, while брал is the imperfective past form of брать.
Here, взял is used because the sentence describes one completed action: the speaker took a key.
- Я взял не тот ключ = I took the wrong key.
- Я брал не тот ключ would sound more like I was taking / used to take the wrong key, or it would shift attention away from the completed result.
In this context, the completed action matters, because it led to the next result: the speaker couldn’t open the door.