Word
Я не понимаю, зачем мы идём туда.
Meaning
I don’t understand why we are going there.
Part of speech
sentence
Pronunciation
Course
Lesson
Questions & Answers about Я не понимаю, зачем мы идём туда.
Why is there a comma before зачем?
In Russian, the comma separates the main clause Я не понимаю (“I don’t understand”) from the subordinate clause зачем мы идём туда (“why we’re going there”). This is analogous to English: “I don’t understand, why…” (though in natural English we’d omit the comma). In Russian grammar, subordinate clauses introduced by interrogative words (зачем, почему, как, etc.) are always set off by a comma.
What does зачем mean, and how is it different from почему?
зачем means “for what purpose” or “to what end.” You use it when you’re asking about the goal or reason behind an action.
почему means “why” in the sense of “what causes something.”
Example:
- Почему идёт дождь? – “Why is it raining?” (What physical cause?)
- Зачем идёт дождь? – “For what purpose is it raining?” (This sounds odd meteorologically, but fits in a poetic or figurative context.)
Why is идём in the present tense instead of some other tense?
In Russian, the present tense идём covers both ongoing actions (“we are going”) and near-future plans (“we’re going to go”). Context tells you if it’s literal movement right now or an upcoming trip. If you wanted to emphasize the future, you could add a time word (e.g., завтра мы идём туда – “tomorrow we’re going there”).
Could you use пойдём instead of идём here?