Breakdown of A despesa supérflua foi eliminada.
Questions & Answers about A despesa supérflua foi eliminada.
Why is it a despesa and not just despesa?
A is the feminine singular definite article, meaning the.
So:
- a despesa = the expense / the expenditure
- despesa on its own = expense / expenditure in a more general or indefinite sense
In this sentence, the speaker is talking about a specific expense, so a is used.
Why is despesa feminine?
In Portuguese, every noun has grammatical gender. Despesa is a feminine noun, which is why it takes:
- the article a
- the adjective form supérflua
- the past participle form eliminada
They all agree with despesa.
A useful pattern is that many nouns ending in -a are feminine, though not always.
Why is the adjective supérflua after the noun?
In Portuguese, adjectives often come after the noun, much more often than in English.
So:
- a despesa supérflua = the superfluous/unnecessary expense
This is the most neutral and natural order here.
You may sometimes see adjectives before the noun in Portuguese, but that often changes the tone, emphasis, or style. For ordinary description, noun + adjective is very common.
What does supérflua mean exactly?
Supérflua means something like:
- superfluous
- unnecessary
- non-essential
- excess
In English, superfluous sounds a bit formal, and the same is true of supérfluo/supérflua in Portuguese. In everyday contexts, it can suggest something that is not needed and could be removed.
Because it describes despesa (feminine singular), it appears as supérflua.
Why does supérflua have an accent mark?
The accent in supérflua shows the stressed syllable.
It is pronounced roughly with the stress on pér:
- su-PÉR-flua
Accent marks in Portuguese are important because they can show:
- where the stress falls
- sometimes vowel quality
So the accent is not optional; it is part of the correct spelling.
What is happening in foi eliminada?
This is a passive construction.
It is made with:
- foi = was (from the verb ser, to be)
- eliminada = past participle of eliminar, agreeing with the feminine singular noun
So:
- foi eliminada = was eliminated
The whole sentence means that the expense received the action rather than performed it.
Compare:
- A empresa eliminou a despesa supérflua. = The company eliminated the unnecessary expense.
- active
- A despesa supérflua foi eliminada. = The unnecessary expense was eliminated.
- passive
Why is it eliminada and not eliminado?
Because in this passive structure, the past participle agrees with the noun being described: a despesa.
Since despesa is:
- feminine
- singular
the participle must also be:
- feminine
- singular
So:
- eliminado = masculine singular
- eliminada = feminine singular
Examples:
- O custo foi eliminado.
- A despesa foi eliminada.
Could this sentence be translated as The unnecessary expense was removed instead of was eliminated?
Yes, depending on context.
Eliminar often means:
- to eliminate
- to remove
- to cut
- sometimes to do away with
In a financial or administrative context, English may naturally use:
- The unnecessary expense was eliminated.
- The unnecessary expense was removed.
- The unnecessary cost was cut.
So eliminated is a very direct translation, but not always the only natural one.
Is despesa the same as gasto?
They are related, but not always identical.
- despesa often means expense, especially in accounting, budgeting, administration, or formal contexts
- gasto often means spending, expense, or outlay, and can sound a bit broader or more everyday depending on context
For example:
- reduzir despesas = to reduce expenses
- os gastos do mês = the month’s spending/expenses
In this sentence, despesa fits well because it sounds like a specific expense item being discussed formally.
Could Portuguese also say this without the passive voice?
Yes. Portuguese often uses active or alternative structures where English might use a passive.
For example:
- Eliminaram a despesa supérflua.
= They eliminated the unnecessary expense. - A despesa supérflua acabou por ser eliminada.
= The unnecessary expense ended up being eliminated. - Eliminou-se a despesa supérflua.
= impersonal/passive-like structure, roughly The unnecessary expense was eliminated
But foi eliminada is perfectly correct and clear, especially in formal written Portuguese.
How would this typically sound in European Portuguese pronunciation?
In European Portuguese, several unstressed vowels are reduced, so it may sound less fully pronounced than a learner expects from the spelling.
Very roughly:
- A may sound like a very short uh
- despesa may sound approximately like dsh-PEH-zuh
- supérflua may compress a bit in fast speech
- foi sounds roughly like foy
- eliminada may reduce some unstressed vowels
A rough learner-friendly approximation might be:
- uh dsh-PEH-zuh su-PER-floo-uh foy ee-lee-mee-NAH-duh
But that is only approximate. European Portuguese pronunciation tends to reduce unstressed vowels more than Brazilian Portuguese, so the spoken rhythm can feel tighter and less syllable-by-syllable than the spelling suggests.
Can I say A despesa desnecessária foi eliminada instead?
Yes. Desnecessária is also possible and often very natural.
Compare:
- supérflua = superfluous, non-essential, slightly more formal
- desnecessária = unnecessary, often more everyday and straightforward
So both work, but the tone is a little different:
- A despesa supérflua foi eliminada.
sounds more formal or administrative - A despesa desnecessária foi eliminada.
sounds slightly more direct and plain
Could the word order be Foi eliminada a despesa supérflua?
Yes, that is also correct.
Both are grammatical:
- A despesa supérflua foi eliminada.
- Foi eliminada a despesa supérflua.
The second version puts the verb first and can sound a bit more formal, report-like, or stylistically marked. The first version is often easier for learners because it follows a more straightforward subject + verb pattern.
So the original sentence is a very good neutral model to learn from.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning PortugueseMaster Portuguese — from A despesa supérflua foi eliminada to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions