Questions & Answers about Esta parte do relatório está errada.
Both esta and essa can mean this in English, but traditionally they are different:
- esta = this, near the speaker
- essa = that, near the listener or something already mentioned
- aquela = that over there, farther away
In real spoken Brazilian Portuguese, many people use essa much more often than esta, even in places where a grammar book might expect esta.
So Esta parte do relatório está errada is perfectly correct, but in everyday Brazilian Portuguese, Essa parte do relatório está errada is also very common.
Portuguese has two main verbs for to be: ser and estar.
Here, está errada is used because the sentence describes a condition or state: this part of the report is wrong.
- estar often refers to a state, condition, or situation
- ser often refers to identity, definition, or more permanent characteristics
So:
- Esta parte do relatório está errada. = This part of the report is wrong.
- Esta parte do relatório é importante. = This part of the report is important.
In practice, errado/errada is very commonly used with estar.