Breakdown of Quando a curva é fechada, o motorista deve diminuir a velocidade.
Questions & Answers about Quando a curva é fechada, o motorista deve diminuir a velocidade.
Literally, yes, fechado / fechada often means closed. But in this sentence it has a different, very common extended meaning.
With roads and turns, curva fechada means a sharp or tight curve, not a physically closed one.
So this is a good example of how a familiar word can have a more specific meaning depending on context.
Because ser is being used to describe a characteristic of the curve, not a temporary condition.
- é fechada = it is a sharp/tight curve
- está fechada would suggest something temporary, and with fechada it could even sound like the road or route is blocked/closed
In Portuguese, ser is generally used for inherent description or classification, while estar is used for states or temporary situations.